Skip to main content

Excessive Fee Lawsuits in Credit Union Land


Lakeland, FL — Credit unions are increasingly coming under fire for excessive overdraft fees, in the same way that major banks have been taken to task for misdeeds such as reorganizing transactions to maximize fees. In October plaintiff Martha Towner filed a Credit Union Excessive Overdraft Fees lawsuit alleging 1st MidAmerica Credit Union charged overdraft fees improperly.

But that’s just the tip of the iceberg, according to various media reports. Since September, at least a dozen credit unions have been hit with class-action Excessive Overdraft Fees lawsuits in nine states, with various pundits weighing in with the observation that this could be the tip of the iceberg.

Towner, in her class-action lawsuit (Towner et al v. MidAmerica Credit Union, and Does 1-100, case No. 3:15-cv-01162, filed October 20, 2015 in US District Court, Southern District of Illinois), claims that her credit union charged her overdraft fees on various transactions, even though there were sufficient funds in her checking account to cover those transactions.

Tracy Fry is another plaintiff who takes exception to the practices of credit unions. Fry asserts in her Credit Union Lawsuit filed in November that MidFlorida Credit Union based in Lakeland charged overdraft fees based on members’ available balances, rather than actual balances. Not only does Fry assert that such methodology is improper, but also constitutes a breach of MidFlorida’s opt-in agreement and was not consistent with disclosures issued to members.

 MidFlorida, it should be noted, serves 220,000 members and boasts $2.3 billion in assets.
 Plaintiffs assert that credit unions with such assets do not need to be nickel-and-diming their members in such fashion. Pundits and industry watchers, meanwhile, say that what we’re seeing is just the tip of an iceberg that will soon reveal itself.

Numerous Credit Union Excessive Overdraft Fees Lawsuits have alleged that credit unions altered the sequence of transactions to maximize fees. While in some cases this has yet to be proven, other lawsuits - such as those of Fry and Towner noted above - accuse the credit unions of misleading practices while basing fees on available balances, rather than actual balances. Industry watchers assert that such lawsuits are not necessarily alleging the credit union is doing anything blatantly improper, but rather is accusing the credit union of misleading conduct.

Attorneys representing the interests of credit unions are urging such organizations to review their disclosures to ensure everything is buttoned-down, thus avoiding any fee, debit or other activity that might be viewed as misleading.


Plaintiffs, on the other hand, aren’t waiting for credit unions to get their respective houses in order. If they have been misled or wronged with unnecessary fees, the credit union is going to hear about it through the plaintiff’s Excessive Overdraft Fees Lawsuit lawyer. 

To read more like this visit: https://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/articles/Credit-Union-excessive-overdraft-fees/credit-union-excessive-overdraft-fees-lawsuit-5-21198.html#.VpjveMIUWM8 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New Analysis Sees Flat Mortgage Market for Next Several Years, Rates to Remain Above 6%

NEW YORK — The U.S. housing market could experience its weakest year in more than a decade as elevated mortgage rates suppress sales and keep home prices nearly flat, according to a Capital Economic s forecast. Capital Economics expects annual home sales to fall to about 4.7 million by the end of 2026, which would represent the slowest pace since 2011. After a modest recovery in 2025, homebuying activity has weakened this year as borrowing costs have increased amid renewed inflation concerns and expectations for higher Federal Reserve interest rates. “Strengthening economic growth will not provide much of a lift to the housing market, which we expect to remain in its structural malaise,” Capital Economics economists wrote, according to Business Insider. Mortgage Rates to Remain Above 6% Capital Economics expects mortgage rates to remain above 6% for at least two more years, continuing to constrain affordability and discourage homeowners with lower-rate mortgages from selling. The aver...

Bipartisan Bill Would Expand Federal Credit Union Investment Authority

WASHINGTON—Reps. Janelle Bynum (D-OR) and Young Kim (R-CA) introduced bipartisan legislation Thursday that would significantly broaden the investments available to federal credit unions, including giving them new authority to invest in corporate debt and asset-backed securities. Young Kim The Credit Union Investment Authority Act would amend the Federal Credit Union Act to expand federal credit unions’ investment authority. Under the bill, federal credit unions could invest in marketable debt obligations issued by companies and other organizations that are not limited to serving credit unions. The legislation would cap a credit union’s investment in the obligations of any single issuer at 10% of its paid-in unimpaired capital and surplus. The measure would also expressly authorize investments in asset-backed securities as defined under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Kathleen Coulombe The bill would require the NCUA board to issue implementing regulations within one year of enactm...

Charting Your Career Path in the Age of AI: 6 Questions to Get You Started

By Peter Myers Increasingly, seasoned talent is stepping out of senior leadership roles and green talent is filling the void. By 2030, 21% of the population will be 65+ (a 25% increase over five years) and Gen Z will represent  ~30% of our workforce.  As institutional knowledge and wisdom voids are created, credit union leadership and governing bodies must also grapple with the reality that 32% of U.S. adults score below the baseline proficiency level in adaptive problem solving, and that a growing number are “ clustered at the bottom levels of proficiency .”   However, big changes also present big opportunities for those committed to developing their leadership skills.  Enter Generative & Agentic AI Not only is the composition of the workforce changing significantly, existing processes and jobs are being upended by Artificial Intelligence. Boards are asking for the AI strategy as employees fear being replaced. It’s a new and evolving landscape that r...

Liquidity Resources

Liquidity Resources Liquidity is a credit union’s capacity to meet its cash and collateral obligations at a reasonable cost. Adequate liquidity is necessary to efficiently meet both expected and unexpected cash flows and collateral needs without compromising the credit union’s daily operations or financial condition. Effective credit union management identifies, measures, monitors, and controls exposure to liquidity risk. Primary Risks In managing expected cash flows, a credit union may experience situations that increase its liquidity risk. These situations include mismatches between sources and uses of funds, market constraints on the ability to convert assets into cash or to access sources of funds (market liquidity), and contingent liquidity events. Changes in economic conditions or exposure to credit, market, operational, legal, and also can affect an institution’s liquidity risk profile. None of these risks are mutually exclusive, and interrelated risks may contribute to increase...

Invest in Education - Invest in Tomorrow

 

Inflation Cools in June Report, But One CU Economist Says There’s One Reason–And it Could Change

WASHINGTON — U.S. consumer inflation cooled more than expected in June, offering relief after several months of elevated price pressures, though economists cautioned the improvement could prove temporary as renewed geopolitical tensions threaten to push energy prices higher. The Consumer Price Index fell 0.4% in June on a seasonally adjusted basis, the largest monthly decline since April 2020, after rising 0.5% in May, according to data released Tuesday by the Bureau of Labor Statistics . Compared with a year earlier, consumer prices rose 3.5%, down from 4.2% in May.  Foot off the Gas Dawit Kebede “Falling gas prices led June’s decline and pulled headline inflation lower year-over-year. Renewed hostilities could complicate the energy picture ahead, and a reversal in gasoline costs would be the most likely channel for that pressure to show up,” said America’s Credit Unions Senior Economist Dawit Kebede. “But softening core prices point to broader-based moderation, suggesting the ea...

Mortgage Rates in the U.S. Rise for First Time in Seven Weeks

 Even as new listings decline, inventory is on the rise because homes are taking longer to sell. By Prashant Gopal | December 30, 2022 CU Times Mortgage rates in the US rose for the first time since mid-November. The average for a 30-year, fixed loan was 6.42%, the highest since early this month and up from 6.27% last week, Freddie Mac said in a statement Thursday. Borrowing costs tracked 10-year Treasury yields, which climbed after a report showed that a consumer-price gauge the Federal Reserve watches closely continued to cool. Inflation is still higher than the central bank would like, and wage growth is stubbornly robust, meaning the Fed’s policy of interest-rate hikes is likely to continue into the new year. For would-be homebuyers, mortgage costs are more than double what they were a year ago and “remain a significant barrier to successfully closing transactions,” said George Ratiu, head of economic research at Realtor.com. Purchases have been declini...

Know Before You Owe: Credit Cards

Know Before You Owe: Credit Cards : Wrtiten by Steve Van Beek Well, the CFPB wasn't lying when it stated its initial focus would be on mortgages, credit cards and student loans. We now have "Know Before You Owe" projects for each one Know Before You Owe: Mortgage Loans Know Before You Owe: Student Loans Know Before You Owe: Credit Cards Yesterday, the CFPB announced their first steps toward clarifying and condensing credit card agreements. Press Release Prototype Credit Card Agreement Listing of Definitions for Prototype Agreement The announcement also came with a pair of blog posts from the CFPB. Shopping for a Credit Card Making Credit Card Agreements Understandable Similar to the other Know Before You Owe projects, the CFPB is actively soliciting feedback on their prototype. Importantly, this is not a proposed rule . However, it is the CFPB's first steps toward collecting information and attempting to clarify credit cards for consu...

7 Things to Do (And Avoid) with SMS/Text in Credit Union Marketing

By not using SMS text messaging for marketing, you are missing a channel with a 98% open rate and a rapid response rate. Consumers love the convenience and are open to receiving personalized and relevant texts from their bank and credit union. Naturally there are some caveats to be aware of. Here are seven pointers. Are you content to have your customers take 90 minutes to respond back to a communication you’ve sent, or would 90 seconds be better? That’s the difference in average response times between email and SMS text. Then there is the open rate: SMS texts have high open rates — up to 98%, according to Gartner and 82% by another source. The average open rate of email is around 20%. If you send an email with a link to a survey to find out what a consumer thinks about the virtual meeting with a lending officer they just had, it may linger in the consumers’ inbox for days, at which point the experience is no longer top-of-mind or the consumer decides to simply delete the ...

'Mixed Signals' in Latest Jobs Report, Says NAFCUs Chief Economist Curt Long

Please join me in extending a warm welcome to NAFCU's Chief Economist and VP-Research, Curt Long! Curt will be a Keynote speaker at our Clearwater Beach Conference and will assist us in embarking on an enlightening journey together as we strive to navigate the future of our industry with confidence and foresight. WASHINGTON–U.S. employers added 209,000 jobs in June, the  Labor Department reported  today, with one CU economist saying the latest job report if full of “mixed signals.” According to the Labor Department, the unemployment rate was 3.6% in June, down slightly from 3.7% in May.  June marked the 30th consecutive month of gains in American payrolls, but also reflected a continued cooling of the labor market. The total was down from a revised 306,000 in May and was the lowest since the streak began, according to the Labor Department. ...