Skip to main content

Excessive Fee Lawsuits in Credit Union Land


Lakeland, FL — Credit unions are increasingly coming under fire for excessive overdraft fees, in the same way that major banks have been taken to task for misdeeds such as reorganizing transactions to maximize fees. In October plaintiff Martha Towner filed a Credit Union Excessive Overdraft Fees lawsuit alleging 1st MidAmerica Credit Union charged overdraft fees improperly.

But that’s just the tip of the iceberg, according to various media reports. Since September, at least a dozen credit unions have been hit with class-action Excessive Overdraft Fees lawsuits in nine states, with various pundits weighing in with the observation that this could be the tip of the iceberg.

Towner, in her class-action lawsuit (Towner et al v. MidAmerica Credit Union, and Does 1-100, case No. 3:15-cv-01162, filed October 20, 2015 in US District Court, Southern District of Illinois), claims that her credit union charged her overdraft fees on various transactions, even though there were sufficient funds in her checking account to cover those transactions.

Tracy Fry is another plaintiff who takes exception to the practices of credit unions. Fry asserts in her Credit Union Lawsuit filed in November that MidFlorida Credit Union based in Lakeland charged overdraft fees based on members’ available balances, rather than actual balances. Not only does Fry assert that such methodology is improper, but also constitutes a breach of MidFlorida’s opt-in agreement and was not consistent with disclosures issued to members.

 MidFlorida, it should be noted, serves 220,000 members and boasts $2.3 billion in assets.
 Plaintiffs assert that credit unions with such assets do not need to be nickel-and-diming their members in such fashion. Pundits and industry watchers, meanwhile, say that what we’re seeing is just the tip of an iceberg that will soon reveal itself.

Numerous Credit Union Excessive Overdraft Fees Lawsuits have alleged that credit unions altered the sequence of transactions to maximize fees. While in some cases this has yet to be proven, other lawsuits - such as those of Fry and Towner noted above - accuse the credit unions of misleading practices while basing fees on available balances, rather than actual balances. Industry watchers assert that such lawsuits are not necessarily alleging the credit union is doing anything blatantly improper, but rather is accusing the credit union of misleading conduct.

Attorneys representing the interests of credit unions are urging such organizations to review their disclosures to ensure everything is buttoned-down, thus avoiding any fee, debit or other activity that might be viewed as misleading.


Plaintiffs, on the other hand, aren’t waiting for credit unions to get their respective houses in order. If they have been misled or wronged with unnecessary fees, the credit union is going to hear about it through the plaintiff’s Excessive Overdraft Fees Lawsuit lawyer. 

To read more like this visit: https://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/articles/Credit-Union-excessive-overdraft-fees/credit-union-excessive-overdraft-fees-lawsuit-5-21198.html#.VpjveMIUWM8 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Cheers to 2026: Thank You for 25 Years"

        As we close out 2025, we want to take a moment to extend our heartfelt gratitude to each and every member and supporter of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions Inc (NCOFCU). For the past two and a half decades, your unwavering support and dedication have been instrumental in helping us achieve our vision of becoming the leading credit union association dedicated to serving first responders and their families.       Thanks to your commitment, we have prioritized education for your volunteer directors and staff, ensuring they are equipped with the knowledge and skills to serve your credit union communities effectively. Together, we have elevated the operational excellence of credit unions through targeted training and support, making a real difference in the lives of first responders and their families.      Your involvement has been the cornerstone of our success, and we are truly grateful for the trust you have p...

Next Gen of Payments Could Leave ACH System Behind, Bank CEO Cautions

NEW YORK–The next generation of payments could leave the Automated Clearing House (ACH) system behind as stablecoins and tokenized deposits move into the banking core, according to one bank CEO. Custodia Bank CEO Caitlin Long said during a discussion with TheStreet Roundtable host Scott Melker that the “tokenized dollars are going to be big. Yes, there’s a distinction between tokenized bank deposits and stablecoins. Yes, right now, all the activity is in stablecoins, but we’re going to link the two in a safe and sound way.” During the discussion, Long cited Citi’s upgraded forecast for the sector, which now projects between $3 trillion and $4 trillion in stablecoins outstanding by 2030, according to Yahoo Finance, which noted Long believes even that range is far too conservative. “Those numbers are still too low,” she said. “I think they’re way too low.” According to Long, the innovation lies in embedding blockchain technology directly into the banking infrastructure rath...

What Trump’s ‘one big beautiful’ tax-and-spending package means for your money!

  Trump’s megabill will bring sweeping changes for household finances. President  Donald Trump  signed his “one big beautiful” tax-and-spending package on July 4 — legislation that will bring sweeping changes to Americans’ finances.  After the  Senate passed its version  on July 1, the House Republicans on July 3  voted to approve  the multi-trillion-dollar domestic policy legislation and send it to Trump’s desk for signature. The final bill makes permanent Trump’s  2017 tax cuts  while adding new relief, including a senior “bonus” to  offset Social Security taxes  and a  bigger state and local tax deduction . The plan also has tax breaks for  tip income , overtime pay and  auto loans , among other provisions.  The GOP’s marquee legislation will also enact deep spending cuts to social safety net programs such as  Medicaid  and food stamp benefits,  end tax credits tied to clean energy  an...

What Will 2026 Hold for CUs?

NEW YORK—As credit unions look to the new year, forecasters heading into 2026 see the U.S. economy cooling but not collapsing, with slower job growth, easing inflation and modest interest-rate cuts forming the backbone of a “soft-landing” outlook that still hinges on big unknowns: trade policy, geopolitics, fiscal decisions in Washington and whether households keep spending after several years of higher prices. Credit union leaders know they have a stake in all of that and more. In addition to the economic forecasts below, the CU Daily also other 2026-related previews, including: 2026 Forecast: The Auto Sales, Lending Trends to be Watching 2026 Forecast: What Companies are Saying About Hiring in New Yea r 2026 Forecast: FASB Puts Two Digital Asset Topics on its Agenda 2026 Forecast: How One Large Bank is Deploying Generative AI 2026 Forecast: Automobile Prices to Remain High as Loan Terms Get Longer 2026 Forecast: Is This a Model for How CUs Might Approach Workforce & AI? What the ...

Email and Text Message Etiquette

As we navigate our everyday communications, I want to emphasize the importance of practicing good email and text message etiquette. This enhances clarity and ensures that everyone feels respected and valued in our interactions. Email Etiquette: 1. Use a Clear Subject Line: A subject line that accurately reflects the content of your email will help recipients know what to expect. 2. Greet Appropriately: Start with an appropriate greeting, such as "Dear [Name]", "Hello [Name]," or "Hi [Name], which sets a positive tone. 3. Acknowledge Receipt: If you receive an email that requires a response, action, or information, please acknowledge its receipt. A simple reply confirming that you have received the email helps the sender know their message was received and provides an opportunity to clarify expectations. 4. Be Concise: Keep your emails clear and to the point. Avoid excessive details unless necessary. 5. Professional Language: Use respectful and professional l...

No New Pennies, New Rules: Treasury Sets Guidance For Cash Transactions

WASHINGTON—For credit unions and their members, the penny’s long goodbye is no longer theoretical—it’s operational. Just before Christmas the U.S. Treasury quietly released a detailed set of  Penny Production Cessation FAQs,  confirming that the federal government has stopped manufacturing new pennies and laying out how businesses, financial institutions, and consumers should prepare as the coin gradually slips out of everyday use. The move reflects a basic math problem: It now costs 3.69 cents to produce a single penny, nearly triple its cost a decade ago. Treasury estimates halting production will save taxpayers $56 million annually, while acknowledging that the coin’s purchasing power—and relevance—has steadily eroded in an economy dominated by electronic payments. What Changes At The Register—And What Doesn’t Despite the halt in production, pennies are not being eliminated. Roughly 114 billion pennies remain in circulation, and the Federal Reserve will continue recirculati...

Syracuse Fire Department Credit Union

Remember, you're not alone with  NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional features: First Responder Credit Union Academy Financial Literacy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Blog Job Board

Money Concepts - The go-to place for all of your members’ financial planning needs.

NCOFCU's 2024 San Antonio Conference Sponsor You know your Members have come to expect personalized care, constant reliability, and unmatched service. By providing holistic planning to your customers, you can… become the go-to place for all of your members’ financial planning needs create an even more loyal and engaged member base differentiate yourself in the market At Money Concepts, we serve as a supportive arm for credit unions, helping them by removing obstacles, providing tools, and advocating for them to help them achieve their goals. Our extensive back-office experience allows financial institutions to focus on what matters — customer relationships strengthened through comprehensive wealth management, financial planning, estate planning, life insurance, and investment solutions. These are the things that you’ve staked your reputation on. And we understand, because these are the same things Money Concepts is known for. Benefits to Your Financial Institution: Proven Method In...

NCOFCU is working hard for you! Coalition of CU Groups Sends Letter to Congress on Tax Exemption

Take Action Coalition of CU Groups Sends Letter to Congress on Tax Exemption May 1, 2025 10:15 am No Comments WASHINGTON–A coalition of credit union organizations has sent a joint letter to Congress in support of the credit union tax exemption. As the CU Daily has been regularly reporting, credit unions are especially  concerned this year that Congress might revoke the tax exemption as it seeks ways to pay for expiring provisions of the 2017 tax cuts, which President Trump wants to see renewed. Sending the letter to Congress were the Defense Credit Union Council (DCUC), America’s Credit Unions (ACU), Credit Union Executive Society (CUES), National Association of Credit Union Chairs (NACUC), National Credit Union Management Association (NCUMA), Inclusiv, TruStage, Earnest Consulting Group (ECG), Callahan and Associates, National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions (NCOFCU), Metropolitan Area Credit Union Management Association (MACUMA), Association of Credit Union Audit and Ri...

7 Things to Do (And Avoid) with SMS/Text in Credit Union Marketing

By not using SMS text messaging for marketing, you are missing a channel with a 98% open rate and a rapid response rate. Consumers love the convenience and are open to receiving personalized and relevant texts from their bank and credit union. Naturally there are some caveats to be aware of. Here are seven pointers. Are you content to have your customers take 90 minutes to respond back to a communication you’ve sent, or would 90 seconds be better? That’s the difference in average response times between email and SMS text. Then there is the open rate: SMS texts have high open rates — up to 98%, according to Gartner and 82% by another source. The average open rate of email is around 20%. If you send an email with a link to a survey to find out what a consumer thinks about the virtual meeting with a lending officer they just had, it may linger in the consumers’ inbox for days, at which point the experience is no longer top-of-mind or the consumer decides to simply delete the ...