Skip to main content

Credit unions and tech experts respond to the Facebook/Cambridge Analytica data "breach of trust."

| March 23, 2018 at 10:30 AM
CUTimes
The events revealed so far in the emerging Facebook and Cambridge Analytica story, may not be a data “breach” but nevertheless, serve as a wakeup call to millions sharing personal information.
Following reports that Cambridge Analytica, a data analysis firm reportedly used in the last presidential campaign, acquired and used Facebook data on some 50 million people without their consent. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg acknowledged his company was partially to blame. “We have a responsibility to protect your data, and if we can’t then we don’t deserve to serve you,” Zuckerberg wrote in a Facebook post. He added, “It was also a breach of trust between Facebook and the people who share their data with us and expect us to protect it. We need to fix that.”
Some compared the exposure to a data breach. San Diego-based The Identity Theft Resource Center, which chronicles data breaches, took the extraordinary step by responding to the recent developments in a press release. “The misuse of millions of Facebook users’ data cannot be classified as a breach one way or another given the lack of specifics currently available.” They did warn consumers about underestimating the value and potential mine-ability of their personal identifying information. Eva Velasquez, president and CEO of the ITRC, said. “Many times, users do not understand that there can be unintended consequences to adding information to their account.”
Gene Fredriksen, chief information security strategist for PSCU, pointed out that people might assume the effects from a breach limited to the breached company. “The truth is that the aggregate information from a series of breaches can build an extensive personal profile.”
In the case of Facebook, Fredriksen suggested everyone should consider information in their profiles, discussions in their posts and revelations through their friends list. He added, “Combine the Facebook information with the financial and account information from an Equifax breach and information from a personnel department breach, such as the Office of Personnel Management, and you can build a cradle-to-grave personal history. A treasure trove for anyone wanting to steal identities, commit other kinds of fraud, or simply resell the bundled information to other criminals.”
This situation does not pose specific risks to credit unions as a routine data breach would, John Buzzard, industry fraud specialist, CO-OP Financial Services, observed. “The vast information in play here was digitized and scored into behavioral analysis for the benefit of the third-party research firm and its clients.”
Buzzard maintained this situation really is a great cautionary tale for consumers who willingly overshare their activities and preferences on social media without properly understanding the possible extrapolation of their activity not in tandem with their personal, financial or political views. “This Big Brother scenario, often feared by consumers, rarely gets put at the top of their list of privacy priorities when it comes to online entertainment and communication.”
Buzzard did provide one caution, “Software developers always tell you about the risk in working with a third-party vendor and now, more than ever, we all have to ensure that our data is leveraged and limited to the scope that most reasonably serves our clients and nothing more. We all have to ask better questions and understand where the buck and the data stops.”
Rebecca Herold, president of the Des Moines, Iowa-based SIMBUS and CEO of The Privacy Professor, said, “There are many dangers to the public, as well as to credit unions, especially those that have pages on Facebook.” Herold maintained credit unions should consider what type of personal details or inclinations are available on pages through comments, posts, and activities.
Herold noted, “Cambridge Analytica performed big data analytics on all this data, and used new types of artificial intelligence, to gain insights into lives (incomes, locations, race, religion, etc.) of people on Facebook.” Those insights could help in trying to persuade members to buy things or use their information to target them as potential crime victims. “We simply do not know all the entities that now have all this data that they collected.”

Check out our line up of excellent speakers in Seattle!




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Credit Where Credit's Due

  Credit Where Credit's Due   Credit reports 101 Used to calculate credit scores   and determine creditworthiness, credit reports are comprehensive documents that detail the credit history of a person or business, including current and former lines of credit, bankruptcy records, and more.  Credit assessments actually started in the 1700s   as a way to evaluate businesses’ financial standing rather than consumers’. The early 1800s brought efforts to standardize the credit reporting system as more businesses were started that needed loans, and the labor movement’s success in the second half of the 1800s led to an increased need for standardized c...

47-Second Loan Décisions. Underwriting in Minutes. How AI is Revolutionizing Turnaround Time in Mortgage Lending

May 27, 2026 CU Today TORONTO–While AI has been deployed across a host of back office functions, on the consumer-facing side its promise is increasingly being seen in mortgage lending, where lenders are promising mortgage approval decisions in as little as 47 seconds, reporting that up to a third of inquiries are now being handled by chatbots, and slashing underwriting time to just minutes. Toronto-based TD Bank Group said it has also deployed its first agentic artificial intelligence system in mortgage lending, reducing the time required to prepare applications for underwriting from an average of roughly 15 hours to less than three minutes. According to a statement from TD Bank, the new AI model automates mortgage pre-adjudication — the process that occurs before a human underwriter reviews an application. The bank said the system classifies borrower documents, extracts and validates financial information, calculates income, performs policy and consent checks, identifies discrepancie...

Trump Accounts Program For Children Moves Forward With New Mobile App Launch

  WASHINGTON—The Treasury Department on Thursday announced the launch of the new Trump Accounts mobile app, marking the next phase of the Administration’s rollout of its new federally backed investment savings program for children ahead of the program’s official July 4 launch date. Donald Trump The app, now available through major mobile app stores, will serve as the primary platform for families to manage and activate Trump Accounts. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the app is intended to give parents and guardians a “simple, secure way” to participate in the program, which was created under the 2025 Republican tax-and-spending package. Families that already submitted IRS Form 4547 to enroll children in the program will begin receiving phased activation emails between now and July 4, according to Treasury. Under the program, eligible children born between Jan. 1, 2025, and Dec. 31, 2028, can receive a one-time $1,000 federal seed contribution into a tax-deferred investment ac...

AI Rapidly Reshaping How Consumers Discover, Compare & Choose Banking Products (But Trust Remains an Issue)

  Frank Diekmann May 26, 2026 SYDNEY — Artificial intelligence is rapidly reshaping how consumers discover, compare and select banking products, forcing financial institutions to rethink their digital marketing and customer acquisition strategies, according to a new report from Bain & Company .  The report, titled “How AI Rewrites the Rules of Brand Discoverability in Banking,” found that AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude and Google Gemini are increasingly acting as the first point of contact between consumers and banks, particularly in Australia, where consumers are using the technology to evaluate products, interpret fees and even prepare applications for loans and credit cards.  According to Bain & Company, the traditional banking sales funnel — once driven by branches, brokers, advertising and search engine rankings — is rapidly shifting toward AI-generated recommendations and responses. ‘Increasingly Influencing Choice’ “AI assistants increasingly influen...

‘Statistically Better Than Humans’: Revolut Says AI Is Transforming AML Monitoring

5/25/2026 08:36 am     WASHINGTON—Artificial intelligence is now outperforming humans in some key areas of financial crime compliance, according to American Banker, which reported comments from Revolut U.S. CEO Cetin Duransoy during Semafor’s Banking on the Future Forum in Washington. Duransoy said AI-driven transaction monitoring at the fintech performs “statistically significantly better than human reviews of the transactions,” allowing human investigators to focus on more complex cases. Duransoy said AI has evolved from a supplemental tool into “core infrastructure” at Revolut, helping the company manage regulatory requirements across 39 countries while also supporting know-your-customer and anti-money-laundering functions. He added that every employee at the company now uses AI in some capacity, including customer service systems powered by large language models that generate responses using actual account information. The executive also warned that financial institutions ...

Letter to Credit Unions Says NCUA Exam Modernization Now Underway

ALEXANDRIA, Va.—NCUA has sent a Letter to Credit Unions ( 21-CU-08 ) detailing the agency's transition to modernized systems. The agency said it will begin this transition in August. NCUA’s efforts will include the implementation of emerging and secure technology that supports the NCUA’s examination, data collection, field of membership, and reporting efforts. “These new applications will streamline processes and procedures and provide significant benefits to credit union users,” NCUA said. Key areas affected: NCUA Connect Admin Portal Consumer Access Process and Reporting Information System (CAPRIS) 1 Modern Examination & Risk Identification Tool (MERIT) Data Exchange Application (DEXA) Training Available To prepare credit unions for the transition to these new systems, NCUA said it will provide credit union user training through various avenues, including: A self-paced training curriculum covering MERIT functionality available through the NCUA’s Learning Management Service An...

Royal Administration Services, Inc. is the Official Conference Sponsor of the 2018 National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions Inc Annual Conference

Hanover, Ma,   Royal Administration Services , Inc. is pleased to announce it is the Official Conference Sponsor for The National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions Inc (NCOFCU) 2018 Annual Conference. NCOFCU’s 2018 Conference will be held in Seattle, Washington September 19-22, 2018. NCOFCU is the nation’s premier professional association of Credit Unions serving firefighters and First Responders and their families. “We are thrilled to Welcome Royal as this year’s Official Conference Sponsor,” said Grant J. Sheehan, Executive Director and CEO of NCOFCU; we are pleased to partner with Royal’s suite of vehicle protection product offerings to our members, and their families. By stepping up its role at the conference, Royal is further demonstrating their support for Firefighters and First Responders and the Credit Union Community. “We share in the Council’s commitment to providing relevant auto lending protection products and services; Royal Administration Services...

Michael Lozoff PA Speaks to Important Lessons from the CFPB-Navy Federal Consent Decree

Important Lessons from the CFPB-Navy Federal Consent Decree On October 11, 2016, the CFPB issued a consent order citing Navy Federal Credit Union for unfair and deceptive debt collection practices. Navy Federal was ordered to pay a $5.5 million civil penalty and to pay affected members $23 million. The CFPB found that the $77 billion Navy Federal violated the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010 (the “CFPAct”) in two principal respects. First, the CFPB said NavyFed made deceptive representations to members about its intent to take legal action against delinquent debtors, its intention to contact members’ military chains of command about their debts, and the effect of delinquency or repayment on consumers’ credit ratings. Second, the CFPB charged NavyFed with unfairly restricting members’ electronic account access—blocking debit cards, ATM usage, and online account functions—when the member had a delinquent credit account. Credit unions nationwide are won...

Cox Lowers Auto Sales Forecast as Rates Rise, 'Outlook Worsening'

Economist says auto loan rates will rise to a 21-year high by year’s end. Interest rates for cars are likely to hit 21-year records by the end of the year, further raising monthly payments and driving down sales as many buyers hold on to aging vehicles a little longer, Cox Automotive analysts said Wednesday. During Cox Automotive’s forecast call, the analysts announced lower forecasts on both new and used vehicles for 2022, compared with its previous quarterly forecast in June . New car sales that in June had been expected to fall 3.4% to 14.4 million this year are now expected to fall 8.1% to 13.7 million. Used car sales that in June had been expected to fall 8.6% to 37.1 million are now expected to fall 10.6% to 36.3 million. The forecast for new car sales was reduced for the third time this year not only because supply shortages haven’t improved as much as expected, but also because higher rates are driving up monthly payments. Cox Automotive Chief Economist Jonathan Sm...

Reactions To Historic NAFCU/CUNA Merger

By Ray Birch CUToday WASHINGTON–Just what will the proposed merger between CUNA and NAFCU mean to individual credit unions? A survey of CUToday.info of CEOs across the country has found generally neutral to positive reactions, with many taking a wait-and-see approach, but others having concerns over a lack of “checks and balances,” compensation paid to association executives, and fewer resources for smaller credit unions. The CUToday.info poll of CEOs on the question of having just one national trade association representing the nation’s 4,800 credit unions also found many see benefits from the consolidation, such as a stronger and more unified voice in Washington, greater efficiencies and potentially lower overall costs for membership. CUToday.info has made multiple attempts to get additional comment from CUNA and NAFCU beyond the statements issued earlier this week and asking for more details on the merger and what lies ahead, but both trade groups have declined comment...