Skip to main content

Strategy During A Crisis

By Chris Howard

CreditUnions.com 
Focusing on products and services won’t build lasting, sustainable success; mission-based strategy helps separate real opportunities from feel-good initiatives.
“Crisis produces opportunity!” It might be a cliché, but it’s true. And the credit unions best positioned to benefit from that opportunity are those driven by strategy.
In times like these, credit unions tend to focus on responding to immediate challenges, often sacrificing future potential to do so. That’s a false choice. Putting all your focus and resources toward emergency triage and first aid is missing the forest for the trees. It’s responding to the crisis but ignoring the resulting opportunity.
Doing the right thing today doesn’t guarantee better outcomes tomorrow. You need a solid plan to turn today’s goodwill into deeper, more sustainable relationships in the future. That’s why investing in strategy is now more important than ever. A long-term, actionable vision, deeply grounded in culture and mission, is what separates organizations that come out of crises with momentum from those that feel lucky to survive.  
But true strategy is hard work, even at the best of times. It requires commitment, energy, and other scarce resources. When the environment is chaotic, those things are dearer and the inevitable opportunity cost is more obvious. And, yet, it’s amid this confusion that strategy is most valuable.

More Than Anything, Members Want To Know You Care

The first job of credit unions during a crisis is to help members survive. By clarifying why you are doing this — by equipping your team with a common language that explains actions in terms of purpose and mission — mission-based strategy can empower you to meet your members’ emotional needs even as you deliver tangible help. That matters. 
People in crisis are afraid, especially if they feel their economic wellbeing is threatened. This shows up in research Gallup is conducting as part of a collaborative credit union program it offers with Callahan & Associates: Members need validation that their fears are reasonable. They need empathy as well as tangible assistance. This reassurance — knowing their credit union cares about their financial wellbeing — is what your members want above all else.
Doing the right thing today doesn’t guarantee better outcomes tomorrow. You need a solid plan to turn today’s goodwill into deeper, more sustainable relationships in the future.
Chris Howard, SVP, Callahan & Associates
Financial wellbeing is more than money, it’s confidence and security as well — your emotional relationship with money. It’s how people perceive their financial situation, express their needs, make critical decisions, and remember events. That means engaging members in these terms can be an effective risk management tool, especially in a world where someone might have to choose who to trust or which obligation to keep current.
An example of this power can be seen in research from March that showed financial wellbeing plummeting. Gallup helped credit unions participating in the collaborative program to provide emotional validation and support alongside financial relief. For those that did so, member financial wellbeing rates have rebounded to almost pre-pandemic levels.  

Turning A Corner

As we start reopening the economy, we are at an inflection point. We turn our attention from survival to sustainability, decisions become harder, and the importance of mission-based strategy only grows. It’s how leaders make the right choices, balance risk, and reward, and determine which opportunities to pursue. And tough as it is to divert scarce resources to future opportunity, there are concrete, actionable steps you can take to get started.
  1. Don’t cancel strategic planning! Can’t meet in person? Do it remotely. But do it! Hire a facilitator — it completely changes the tone and productivity — and make sure your agenda specifically addresses mission and strategy. Now is a great time to reset your timeframe and talk about where you want to be 10 years from now.
  2. Engage your board and management team in thinking differently.
    A strategy is a lens through which to evaluate your biggest choices: What are the long-term impacts on member engagement and wellbeing? Is this consistent with your mission? Will this decision move you closer to your long-term strategic objective? And if not, why not?
  3. Think beyond your financial statements. Strategic goals are more than just numbers; they are outcomes and impact. And long-term risk and reward can’t be measured accurately on the quarterly balance sheet or next year’s projected income statement. Strategy needs to be managed for the next 12 years more than the next 12 months.
  4. Invest strategically, especially where it only involves small changes to existing efforts. Research shows members want three kinds of emotional support right now:
    • “Build my hope.”
    • “Increase my peace of mind.”
    • “Reduce my stress.”
    Cross-functional teams focusing on these areas can help align emotional and financial support, improve how it’s perceived and valued by members (increasing impact while lowering cost and risk), socialize the idea of organizing around impact instead of product lines, and lay a foundation for greater member engagement and wellbeing.
It’s not enough to play it safe. Focusing on products and service won’t deliver the emotional engagement with members that builds lasting, sustainable success. For that, credit unions need a mission-based strategy to help them separate real opportunities from feel-good initiatives. 
The strategy provides a common framework for thinking and speaking, creates clarity around focus, investment, and message, and helps credit unions deliver on their mission. During times of crisis, it’s critical. Daily, existential decisions will determine member financial wellbeing, employees’ professional futures, and your long-term relevance. These stakes are too high to be left to gut, intuition, or chance.


Read more: Strategy During A Crisis | Credit Unions http://www.creditunions.com/blogs/industry-insights/strategy-during-a-crisis/#ixzz6Mt2ufAvO

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Cutting Through The Stablecoin Noise—What Credit Unions Actually Need To Know Now

By Ray Birch DOVER, Del.—By any measure, stablecoins have quickly become one of the most talked-about—and least understood—topics in credit union boardrooms. The pressure to “do something” is building, fueled by headlines, fintech momentum and a growing fear of being left behind. But according to InvestiFi CEO Kian Sarreshteh, that urgency may be misplaced. “There’s a lot of FOMO right now,” Sarreshteh said. “If I don’t adopt a stablecoin solution this year, I’m going to be left behind. I would argue pretty strongly that’s very far from the truth.” Instead of rushing to sign up for a Stablecoin pilot, Sarreshteh said credit unions should begin with a more fundamental question: what problem are you actually trying to solve? While stablecoins are often discussed as a potential challenger to traditional payment rails dominated by Visa and Mastercard, he believes that kind of mass-market disruption remains years away—especially in the U.S., where consumers already have fast, convenient opt...

Senate Banking To Vote Thursday On Landmark Digital Assets Bill

“NCOFCU appreciates the Senate Banking Committee’s continued work during next week’s markup hearing to establish a clear and responsible regulatory framework for digital assets,” said the National Council of Fire Fighter Credit Unions (NCOFCU) leadership. “As lawmakers consider this legislation, it is essential that first responder credit unions are recognized as a vital part of the financial services ecosystem and are not overlooked in the evolving digital asset landscape. Credit unions serving police, fire, EMS, and other emergency personnel must have equitable access to innovation, regulatory clarity, and the tools necessary to continue supporting the financial readiness and resilience of America’s first responders.” Grant Sheehan CEO WASHINGTON—The Senate Banking Committee will vote on the long-awaited CLARITY Act this Thursday, Committee Chairman Tim Scott (R-SC) announced Friday. Tim Scott The announcement marks a potentially major step forward for legislation that would establis...

The Most Overlooked Growth Opportunity in First Responder Credit Unions

Credit unions spend enormous amounts of time, energy, and marketing dollars trying to acquire new members. But many institutions — especially sponsor-based first responder credit unions — are sitting on one of the most valuable growth opportunities already inside their existing membership base. The joint owner population. Every day, firefighters, police officers, EMTs, dispatchers, and other first responders join credit unions through sponsor relationships. During account opening, spouses or partners are often added as joint owners for convenience. They help manage the household finances. They use the debit card. They log into online banking. They interact with the credit union regularly. Yet in many cases, they never actually become full member-owners of the cooperative. They are connected to the institution — but not fully part of it. And that creates a major strategic opportunity. Why Joint Owner Conversion Matters For sponsor-based credit unions, converting joint owners into full m...

How to Comply in the New World of Complaints

NASHVILLE–It’s not enough anymore to receive a member complaint and to respond with just an apology. Not surprisingly, with Washington now much more involved, member complaints have become a formal process with penalties involved when those complaints aren’t addressed and resolved.  That has required credit unions to create complaint tracking systems and one CU that has done so shared some of its processes and lessons learned during the NAFCU annual meeting here. One thing that was clear: complaints are not just what a teller might hear. Complaints can come via numerous channels, including regulators, and can be related to everything from credit reports to RESPA letters to mortgage rules and much more.  “Complaints run the gamut, but the key is complaint management,” said Mitchell B. Klein, an attorney who is also the chief risk officer with Citadel FCU. “All of these types of complaints need to be managed in some fashion and in a timely way. You don’t want to get in ...

7 Secrets For Merger Success | Credit Unions

These best practices will ensure your next merger won’t be your last. By Aaron Pugh  With six mergers completed since 2009 and three more on the immediate horizon, Credit Union of Southern California ($781.8M, Whittier, CA) — commonly referred to as CU SoCal — attributes just over half of its branch footprint and about 70% of growth achieved in the past five years to merger activity. On the opposite side of the country, The Summit Federal Credit Union ($723.7M, Rochester, NY) averaged close to one merger a year between 2003 and 2011, increasing its assets by more than $445 million and adding 12 branches in three regional markets beyond its original Rochester and Seneca Falls footprint. Despite the prevalence of this activity, neither of these institutions has ever actively sought out any merger partner. Instead, they’ve been responding to increased demand from small-to-mid-sized credit unions for cooperative alliances, both for survival and for the enhanced economies of scale ...

Ransomware: 'It's A Growing Issue'

MADISON, Wis.—Ransomware attacks, already a quiet concern that has been growing among credit unions, are expected to dramatically increase this year—with one analyst saying there is “no silver bullet” to prevent the threat. Ransomware is a type of malicious software designed to block access to a computer system or PC until a sum of money is paid. In the case of a financial institution, crooks first use the malware to encrypt the contents of the FI’s data and then extract a ransom in exchange for decrypting the information and allowing the victim to regain access. It’s an issue, according to one regulator source who asked for anonymity that has been growing within credit unions, many of which have paid ransoms to regain access to their data and have chosen not to speaking publicly about the crime. “This has become a huge problem,” said Ken Otsuka, senior consultant in CUNA Mutual Group’s risk management department, adding that CUNA Mutual Group’s cyber liability coverage data d...

Just Out! - NCUA Stablecoin Plan Opens Door To Credit Union-Backed Digital Dollar Issuers

ALEXANDRIA, Va.—A sweeping new NCUA proposal to implement the GENIUS Act could open the door for credit union-backed stablecoin issuance, but only through separately licensed subsidiaries operating under an extensive new federal regulatory framework that limits risks to the Share Insurance Fund. The 269-page supplemental proposed rule issued Friday lays out how “permitted payment stablecoin issuers” affiliated with federally insured credit unions would be supervised, examined and regulated by the NCUA, while also establishing rules covering reserves, liquidity, custody, operational risk, cybersecurity, anti-money laundering compliance and disclosure standards. The proposal supplements an earlier February 2026 proposal by the agency focused primarily on licensing and investments in stablecoin issuers. Federally insured credit unions themselves would still be prohibited from directly issuing payment stablecoins under the GENIUS Act. Instead, issuance would have to occur through a separa...

NCUA - How Many NCUA Staff are Leaving, & What Are They Taking With Them? Here are 3 Viewpoints

ALEXANDRIA, Va.–NCUA may have already reached its target of reducing staff by 20% as the Trump administration pressures regulatory agencies to reduce headcount, although the agency has not confirmed what several people said they are hearing. Thos same individuals have also expressed their concerns that a lot of “institutional memory” may be headed out the door. During a podcast hosted by Mark Treichel, who during his 33-year career worked his way up from examiner to executive director, John McKechnie, an advocate for credit unions on Capitol Hill who spent five years at NCUA as director of public and congressional affairs, and Geoff Bacino, who now leads an association management firm and who served on the NCUA board, shared what they have heard from inside NCUA regarding the staff reductions. Mark Treichel Updates & Board Meetings The NCUA board was to hear an update on that issue during its April board meeting, but after board members Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka were fired by Pr...

The Role of the Board Chair

Tim Harrington, CPA   CEO, TEAM Resources The Role of the Board Chair Recently I had the chance to spend some time with a great group of board members . One of the things we talked about was the role of the board chair. I thought this well worth putting down on *paper* as it were. The role of the chairperson is multi-faceted, complex, and often changing within the context of the organization’s dynamic. Unfortunately, there’s no perfect set of “rules.” But there are some guidelines. Here are our “tips” on navigating the position successfully: Roles Facilitator  – The board chair must draw together the individual directors into a team, working together on behalf of the membership and the credit union. To do that, s/he must wrangle individual personalities, draw out conversation from some, and rein it in from others. Having a solid understanding of the personalities of each director … and the CEO helps the chair keep things on track, moving forward, and civil. ...

Hood: Credit unions are safe and sound

Hood’s term on the NCUA Board will expire in August.  NCUA Board Member Rodney Hood appeared via live stream with Brad Barnes, Air Academy Credit Union, and Amy McGraw, Tropical Financial Credit Union. The regulator lauds strong membership, asset, and loan growth. Despite recent headwinds, including high-profile bank failures, the credit union movement is still safe and sound, says Rodney Hood, NCUA board member, and immediate past chairman. “We’re not seeing the contagion like at other financial institutions,” says Hood, who addressed the 2023 CUNA Finance Council Conference Monday via live stream. The Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) crisis was one of confidence, he says. Ninety percent of SVB’s deposits were uninsured. In comparison, more than 91% of credit union deposits are insured. “We don’t have those entanglements,” Hood says. “That bodes well for our future.”  He lauded America’s 4,800 credit unions for growing membership to 135 million, assets to $2.2 trill...