Skip to main content

How to Spot a Board in Trouble: Tim Harington

This is not a comprehensive list. In fact, we’d like to hear from others the things that they’ve seen or what they look for. We’re sure our smart readership has some things to add. This is also not a checklist. We’re not suggesting that once you’ve identified all eight of these you’ve found your troubled board. (Notice that some of these are countervailing.) But these are things that show up regularly and have been present when dealing with troubles.
How to Spot a Board in Trouble, Red Flags
How to Spot a Board in Trouble
  1. No turnover on the board – Why? Lack of desire for change? Lack of recruiting? Difficulty in recruiting? Contentment with the status quo?
  2. Heavy turnover on the board – Again, why?
  3. No diversity on the board – this means you really don’t represent the demographics of your membership. (We doubt your field of membership is made up exclusively of 67-year-old white dudes.)
  4. The CEO attends all committee meetings – Is this the board’s overreliance on the CEO? Or is this the CEO's inability to let go of control?
  5. No executive sessions – This suggests that there is a lack of trust somewhere (or a lack of understanding of executive sessions). See our blog post about this topic.
  6. Same chair for the last 20+ years – This is a red flag about resistance to change. (This could be a chair that has been begging for years for someone else to take the helm, which is also a red flag.)
  7. Four CEOs in the last five years – Not long ago we talked about the “rebound” CEO, which means it’s very possible to have had three CEOs in the last five years and that’s only a bump in the road and not a red flag. But the minute you reach the number “four” this is a giant red flag.
  8. All of the board members are from the single SEG sponsor (even though the CU has had a community charter for years). Do we have to explain this one? See #6.
How to Spot a Board in Crisis
How to Spot a Board in Crisis
Some of you are going to disagree. We’re fine with that. 

Some of you are going to point out a piece of anecdotal evidence that contradicts what we’ve said above. We’re also fine with that, and we still strongly make our claim despite your story.

Let’s duke it out and talk about it.

Yes. Context is everything. These are red flags that cause us to explore and ask more questions.

 Team Resources

7049 E. Tanque Verde Rd., PMB 136
Tucson, AZ 85715

Phone: 520.290.5721
Fax: 520.290.8378
Cell: 520.906.7501





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What Should Credit Unions Know About Stablecoins?

  Congress is considering new legislation around cryptocurrency, and these new tools could have profound implications for the industry. Andrew Lepczyk Creditunions.com Cryptocurrency is seemingly everywhere in 2025, including member’s  virtual “wallets .” A  2022 study from CUNA  – now known as America’s Credit Unions – found cryptocurrency ownership among credit union members stood at 39%, as opposed to 17% of the general population. In some ways this makes sense; many Americans who feel excluded from the traditional financial system are drawn to cryptocurrency, mirroring the relationship many members have with their credit union. While there are plenty of enthusiasts, cryptocurrency also has its detractors. Many dismiss crypto ownership as speculative, and cryptocurrency as nothing more than an overly risky, volatile asset. Public failures of companies like FTX have only made the critics louder. A  recent study from the Pew Research Center  found 63% of r...

Before You Push Send!

  The Art of Thoughtful Discourse in a Noisy World In an era where opinions flood every corner of social media, news platforms, and casual conversations, the sheer volume of voices can be both inspiring and overwhelming. Everyone seems to have something to say, and while it's a beautiful thing to witness such diverse perspectives, it raises an important question: how can we ensure that our contributions are meaningful and resonate with others? The Power of Evidence-Based Opinions At the heart of impactful communication lies the value of substantiation. Personal views are indeed intriguing and can spark engaging discussions. However, without solid evidence or context to support them, these opinions can quickly lose their potency. When we articulate our thoughts without backing them up, we risk contributing to the noise rather than enhancing the dialogue. To make meaningful contributions, it’s essential to prioritize reasoning over reflexivity. Taking the time to gathe...

Mastering Mortgages - A little History for the Day

  Mastering Mortgages     Background Mortgages  are a type of property loan that financial institutions, such as banks and credit unions, can offer when a prospective buyer decides against paying a property’s full cost in cash.  The lender provides funds to the borrower to purchase the property, and the borrower pays them back over a fixed time period, typically between 10 and 30 years. On top of paying back the base cost of the property, also called the “principal,” the borrower pays monthly interest to the lender.  Most buyers also pay a down payme...

Live Podcast with Bonnie Sensing, Executive VP of Nashville Firemen's Credit Union on BSA

Jo in us in this live episode as Grant Sheehan, CCUE | CEO of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions (NCOFCU), interviews Bonnie Sensing, Executive VP of Nashville Firemen's Credit Union. We break down the BSA complex regulations, explore BSA compliance strategies, and discuss real-world implications for directors and staff. BSA Podcast YouTube NCOFCU Podcasts  

Unlocking the Future: How Generative AI is Transforming Credit Unions

  Unlocking the Future: How Generative AI is Transforming Credit Unions In the rapidly evolving financial landscape, technology plays an increasingly pivotal role. Among the most exciting advancements is Generative AI, which is poised to transform how credit unions operate and serve their members. Read on to discover how generative AI can reshape the member experience and optimize operations within credit unions. What is Generative AI? Generative AI refers to a class of artificial intelligence that can create new content—such as text, images, and audio—based on existing data. Unlike traditional AI, which focuses on analyzing and recognizing patterns, generative AI synthesizes new information, offering exciting possibilities for financial institutions, particularly credit unions. The Applications of Generative AI in Credit Unions Personalized Financial Advice Credit unions pride themselves on their member relationships, and generative AI can enhance these connections....