Skip to main content

Margins Remain Under Pressure

Credit union earnings will be continue to be depressed over the next two years because of low interest rates and less non-interest income, according to CUNA’s latest forecast.

CUNA’s economic and credit union forecast released Feb. 12 expects the economy to improve much faster than it forecast in November, but it remains pessimistic about credit union margins.

CUNA estimates return on average assets (ROA) for the 12 months ending Dec. 31 was 0.65%, down from 0.93% for 2019. And, it is predicting that ROA will fall to 0.50% both in 2021 and 2022. The forecast is a product of collaboration between economists at CUNA and at CUNA Mutual Group, both of Madison, Wis.

Last year’s ROA “was propped up by fees from significant sales on mortgages and PPP [Payroll Protection Program] loans,” said Jordan van Rijn, CUNA senior economist and the report’s author. “Overall, the very low interest rates and falling loan to share ratio means that credit unions will be forced to place funds in low yielding investments, and newly disbursed loans will receive tiny interest margins.”
However, CUNA has been underestimating credit union earnings. Its current forecast assumes ROA of 0.66% for the fourth quarter of 2020, up from its November forecast of 0.35%.

Callahan & Associates, the credit union company based in Washington, D.C., last week estimated 0.83% ROA for the fourth quarter, up from 0.81% in 2019’s fourth quarter and 0.79% in 2020’s third quarter.

NCUA call reports for the 10 largest credit unions show their fourth-quarter ROA was 1.01%, up from 0.95% in 2019’s fourth quarter and 0.60% in 2020’s third quarter.

Data from the Top 10 credit unions and Callahan show the improvement came from a sharp drop in loan loss provisions and higher non-interest income, particularly from mortgage sales. NCUA’s full set of fourth-quarter data is expected in early March.

For the broader picture, CUNA forecasts a faster economic recovery this year than it had forecast in November.

Last year, Gross Domestic Product (GDP) fell 3.5%, its worst full-year drop since 1946. The unemployment rate fell from its April peak to 6.3% in January, but the pace of recovery slowed significantly over the past few months.

Yet CUNA cited signs of hope in falling COVID-19 cases, rising vaccinations and President Biden’s plan for an additional $1.9 trillion stimulus package that includes expanded unemployment benefits, support for schools and hospitals, and additional direct payments to households.

“For credit unions, the additional stimulus will dramatically increase savings growth and help maintain relatively healthy portfolio quality, and the recovery and low interest rates will support modest loan and membership growth,” van Rijn said. “However, low interest rates will squeeze earnings and the loan to share and net worth ratios will continue to fall.”

Van Rijn said the most significant changes from its previous November forecast include:

  •     The economy will grow 3.5% in 2021, up from its previous forecast of 2.5%.
  •     Consumer Price Index inflation will rise 2.1% in 2021, up from its previous estimate of 1.2%.
  •     The unemployment rate will fall to 5.5% by year’s end, down from its previous forecast of 7%.
  •     Savings will grow 15% this year, up from its previous 8% forecast, and assets will grow 13.5%, up from its previous 7% estimate. Both revisions are based on the additional stimulus expected this year.
  •     Credit union portfolio quality is expected to be better than previously anticipated. Delinquency rates will rise only slightly to 0.80% in 2021, down from its previous estimate of 1.10%. Net charge offs will rise to 0.60%, down from its previous forecast of 0.80%.


CUNA’s forecast assumes vaccinations will reach roughly half of the population by the summer, the U.S. will approach herd immunity during the second half of the year, and, “given Democratic control of Congress,” Biden will be able to sign a stimulus plan roughly equal to the one proposed in March or April.

Credit unions can expect continued sluggish growth in loans, and fast growth in savings. As a result, the loan-to-share ratio will fall from 73.6% as of Dec. 31 to 65.6% by the end of this year and 64.4% by the end of 2022.

Total loans were $1.9 trillion as of Dec. 31, up 5% from a year earlier, largely on the strength of mortgages and PPP loans. CUNA expects portfolios will grow another 5% this year and 8% in 2022.

“We expect auto lending to recover and mortgage lending to remain strong,” van Rijn said. “However, headwinds to faster growth include fewer PPP loans and households using stimulus funds and mortgage refinancing to pay down existing debt, such as credit cards.”

Savings grew 20.6% to $1.62 trillion last year. “Stimulus will continue the strong deposit growth at credit unions and CUNA economists anticipate savings growth of 15% for 2021 mostly concentrated in the first and second quarters before falling to 5% in 2022,” he said.


Jim DuPlessis CU Times


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NCOFCU Newsletter

The Bucket Coach is a financial advice book designed by Fire Services Credit Union, Tronto, Canada. and written exclusively for Fire Fighters It's a practical guide for household financial management, including investments, credit and mortgages, and retirement. Developed with contributions from Fire Fighters," NCOFCU Newsletter : " Kevin Connolly Chief Executive Officer    Fire Services Credit Union Phone: 416-440-1294 ext 301  Toll Free: 1-866-833-3285 E-mail:  kevin@firecreditunion.ca 1997 Avenue Rd Toronto, ON M5M 4A3 

How Stablecoins Could Prove to Be Anything But Stable for CUs That Don’t Get Moving

LOST PINES, Texas–With the GENIUS Act enacted and the countdown on for NCUA and regulators to get rules in place for stablecoins, credit unions were told it’s “go time” to begin preparing for a new technology that could “eat the lunch” of interchange. The cautionary words came from  Dr. Lamont Black , an associate professor at the Driehaus College of Business at DePaul University, where among other things he teaches a graduate course on cryptocurrency, and who is also a fellow in Filene’s Credit Union of the Future Center of Excellence, and who s well-known to many in credit unions for his work and insights.  After several years of speaking to credit unions on crypto, he told  Catalyst Corporate’s  Strategic Summit meeting he has pivoted now due to the rapid change taking place, and in addition to talking about AI (see separate reporting in the CU Daily), he has a warning for CUs when it comes to another emerging technology. Eating the Lunch of Payments “I believe st...

Sunday Reading - What is the Dow Jones?

    What is the Dow Jones? Created in 1896, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is one of the world’s oldest and most widely recognized stock indexes—a measure tracking the stock performance of a selected group of companies ( see most recent data ). Originally designed to track America’s leading industrial firms, the Dow has evolved into a cultural and financial shorthand for the health of the US economy. As of 2025, it measures 30 major companies —like McDonald's, Boeing, and Nike—across sectors such as technology, healthcare, finance, and consumer goods.  Unlike most modern indexes, which are weighted by the total value of a company’s shares, the DJIA uses a price-weighted formula —meaning stocks with higher share prices exert more influence, regardless of company size. The DJIA has been updated 59 times since its creation to reflect changes in the US economy ( see ch...

Fed Chair Says Strength of Economy Allowing it to be Patient With Any Rate Cuts

WASHINGTON–Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell said the strength of the economy is giving the central bank flexibility to be patient when it comes to cutting rates. Jerome Powell This year has been filled with predictions over when the Fed will move to reduce rates, including by credit union economists. But inflation has been more stubborn than many had forecast, and most now say it will be June at the earliest before the Fed makes any move. Last week, a new report showed inflation in February was 2.5%, far below the 7% peak seen in 2022 and closer to the Fed’s 2% target. In an interview last week with the National Public Radio’s Marketplace program, P...

Zelle Says It Will Allow Users to Make International Payments Using Stablecoins

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz .–   Zelle  has announced plans to allow users to start making international payments using stablecoins. The move by Early Warning Services, which operates the P2P payments network Zelle and which is owned by a consortium of large banks, comes in the wake of the passage of the GENIUS Act, which is designed to usher stablecoins into the regulated financial system. Stablecoins are a digital currency that is pegged to a fiat currency such as the U.S. dollar. As the CU Daily reported  here , credit unions were strongly urged during an event last week to not just start paying attention to stablecoins but to begin taking action as interchange income is threatened. Similarly, analysts said the move by Zelle to help users move money across borders is a defensive move in response to what is expected to be the growing use of stablecoins by consumers and businesses. Early Warning Services did not indicate how it would work or when it would launch, according to sever...

Your Credit Union CAN Use Public Fund Deposits To Fund Assets

By Corporate One Federal Credit Union Once largely thought of as taboo, the use of external funding is now widely accepted throughout the credit union industry. In fact, the NCUA has required all credit unions to seek multiple liquidity sources and document those sources in their liquidity policy. As the acceptance of external funding has improved, credit unions are increasingly sourcing funds from many channels, including the Federal Home Loan Bank System, the corporate credit union network, and several non-member deposit channels, such as public fund deposits. Yes, public fund deposits are being increasingly sourced to fund credit union assets. Increasing Growth, Benefits, And Uses Total member and non-member government deposits totaled $5.4 billion at year-end 2017. This is an increase of 27% since 2015. While this amount pales in comparison to total deposits and other liabilities, how important are these deposits to the nearly 500 credit unions who report them?...

Sunday Reading - What is the Erie Canal?

  Gateway to the West     What is the Erie Canal? The Erie Canal is a 363-mile waterway in New York connecting the Great Lakes to the Atlantic seaboard, from the Hudson River at Albany to Lake Erie at Buffalo ( see map ). Initiated in 1817 for $7M (nearly $200M today), the canal was America’s first major infrastructure project and revolutionized trade and commerce in the United States. The project relied on self-taught amateurs —including teachers, judges, and surveyors. The workers, nearly 50,000, dug the entire canal with hand tools, picks, and gunpowder (dynamite had not yet been invented). The original Erie Canal had 83 locks, each designed to be...

Powell Rejects Any Plan for Fed to Intervene in Secondary Market to Bring Down Rates

  Frank Diekmann October 20, 2025 2:22 am No Comments PHILADELPHIA–Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell said there are no plans for the central bank to directly intervene in secondary mortgage markets in an attempt to help bring down mortgage rates, an idea some have proposed as a means of addressing the affordability crisis In housing. Jerome Powell Speaking at the  National Association for Business Economics  conference in Philadelphia, Powell spoke to the Fed’s progress with “quantitative tightening,” that is, its work to reduce the more than $6 trillion of securities it holds on its  balance sheet . Read more about the Balance Sheet HERE Those holdings include approximately $2 trillion in mortgage-backed securities (MBS), which are bundles of home loans that are packaged together and sold to investors, usually by middlemen  Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac , noted Realtor.com. Rolling Off Balance Sheet As the report noted, the Fed dramatically increased M...

No Bonuses, No Problem: Why Credit Unions Are Rethinking Incentive Models

Cooperatives across the country are taking a fresh look at employee motivation, with some moving toward a more holistic approach to compensation. Marc Rapport Point/Counterpoint: This story is part of Callahan’s new “Point/Counterpoint” series, examining credit union issues from multiple perspectives. Want a different take on incentives? Learn how two credit unions align staff efforts with organizational goals to boost the bottom line and enhance member value in “Incentives That Power Performance And Improve Outcomes.” Top-Level Takeaways Capital Credit Union’s transition away from individual performance-based incentives has resulted in improved employee engagement, lower turnover, and better member service. Seattle Credit Union is still evaluating the effectiveness of incentive programs, balancing ...

New from AutoLink

New from AutoLink