Skip to main content

Can Small CUs Survive the 4rth Industrial Revolution?

By Homer Fager

The Third Industrial Revolution period of the 1950s through 1990s witnessed the beginning of the decline of the small credit unions. In the 1960s the number of credit unions, including state and federal institutions, exceeded 20,000. The 1980s brought new technology to the industry from personal computers to the introduction of the first credit union-sponsored ATM. During the next three decades 10,000 credit unions were lost and in the last decade alone 2,000 have vanished.

Continuation of this rate of decline means the “small entity” credit unions may be lost within the next 15 to 20 years.

These Third Industrial Revolution banking structural changes were the beginning of the decline of the “small entity”credit union.

The Fourth Industrial Revolution, also referred to as 4IR or Industry 4.0, has changed the 21st century and will continue to change our society as did none of the other three revolutions. More has been accomplished in the last 250-plus years of human history than during the previous 2,500 years.

According to The World Economic Forum the first three periods included mechanical equipment, electricity/mass production, and electronics/automated production, respectively. The fourth revolution is assumed to have began after the 1990s but before 2013, the year Klaus Schwad first published his book, “The Fourth Industrial Revolution.”

Now, 5G (fifth generation technology of broadband cellular networks) and COVID-19 have advanced the application of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, with “cyber-physical systems” blurring the lines between the physical, digital, and biological worlds of influence. Per Klaus Schwab, “87% of young people in the U.S. say their smart phone never leaves their side and 44% use their camera function daily.”

He further noted how “now the world requires companies to respond in real time wherever they are or their customers or clients.”

The Millennial generation, also known as the “now gen” desires to conduct retail activities in real time, from their purchasing of goods to their retail banking P2P relations. The traditional banking industry faces serious threats from emerging digital modes to accessing banking services to being irrelevant at every stage of 4IR massive technology disruptions.

What Must Be Understood

Continue reading

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NCUA Board briefed on four topics

The NCUA Board heard briefings on four topics during its meeting Thursday, including the status of the deregulation initiative, a clarification regarding existing rules applicable to brokered and reciprocal deposit arrangements, and the agency’s 2026-2030 Strategic Plan and 2026 Annual Performance Plan.   Acting Director of the Office of Examination and Insurance Amanda Parkhill provided an overview of Phase 1 of the agency’s Deregulation Project, which focuses on targeted, technical changes to remove outdated or unnecessary requirements and improve clarity. The agency made it clear that the effort will likely continue into late 2026 or early 2027, evolving over time based on policy priorities and stakeholder input.   NCUA General Counsel Frank Kressman briefed the board on brokered and reciprocal deposit arrangements and the NCUA’s FAQs on this topic. The briefing demonstrated how a brokered deposit network operates with respect to low-income designated (LID) FICUs ...

How Your Bank/Credit Union Can Fight ‘Soft Switching’ — and Even Steal a Few Accounts of Your Own

Your Members Aren't Leaving in a Huff, They're Just Fading Away. Here's How to Stop It. “Soft switching” is picking up as Americans’ financial activity continues to fragment among multiple players, according to new research from JD Power. This trend has implications both for banks and credit unions that want to retain and grow existing relationships, as well as those that would also like to expand by snapping up accounts from other institutions. Key risk:  Once someone establishes a relationship with another provider, their one-time primary financial institution risks slipping into second place — or even losing the relationship entirely. Need to Know: The average checking account customer now has three deposit accounts at different institutions, the study found. One out of five consumers moved money away from their primary financial institution in the past three months, according to the study, an increase over the 17% rate seen in the previous edition. Departures aren’t sud...

Sunday Reading - Landmine Rat Honored

  Landmine Rat Honored   Cambodia unveiled the world’s first statue honoring a landmine-detecting rat (w/photo) Friday. Magawa the rat lived to 8 years old and identified more than 100 landmines and other explosives from 2016 to 2021.  There are more than 100 African pouched rats deployed in landmine detection operations across the world. To identify mines, the rats are trained to sniff out explosive compounds like trinitrotoluene, or TNT. (The rats are not heavy enough to trigger detonation.) In Cambodia, up to 6 million landmines remain undiscovered, most planted during three decades of conflict, from the Vietnam War era through Cambodia's civil war . Since 1979, roughly 20,000 people have been killed in Cambodia, and roughly 40,000 wounded as a result of the mines. Magawa cleared more than ...

It All Starts in the Boardroom

It all starts in the boardroom—but the consequences are felt far beyond it. When Governance Breaks Down, Members Pay the Price Credit unions are built on a simple but powerful idea: they are owned by their members. Unlike traditional banks, where shareholders drive decisions, credit unions are meant to operate democratically—guided by a volunteer board elected by the very people they serve. But that model only works when participation exists. A governance breakdown happens when the people elected to oversee an institution stop truly representing the people who own it. In credit unions, this breakdown doesn’t usually come from scandal or sudden failure. It happens quietly, over time—through disengagement. The Root of the Problem: Low Engagement Most credit union members don’t vote. Board election turnout is typically in the low single digits. In some cases, it’s barely measurable. That means a very small percentage of the membership is effectively deciding who governs an institution th...

It's Financial Literacy Month

April is Financial Literacy Month—a time dedicated to empowering individuals and families with the knowledge and tools needed to make informed financial decisions. Whether you're budgeting, saving, managing debt, or planning for the future, improving your financial literacy can have a lasting impact on your well-being. We invite you to explore our Consumer Education website, where you'll find helpful resources, tips, and guidance to support your financial journey. If you find it valuable, please share it with your family and friends—because financial knowledge is even more powerful when it’s shared. https://www.ncofcu.org/financial-literacy  ================================================= Remember, you're not alone with  NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional features: Annual Conference First Responder Credit Union Academy Financial Literacy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Advocacy  

Sunday Reading - Why the IRS is necessary

  'Taxman'   Why the IRS is necessary The Internal Revenue Service, or IRS, is a division of the US Treasury Department created in 1862   that enforces the Internal Revenue Code —Title 26 of the US Code, a compilation of federal statutes—and, effectively, oversees tax collection. In 2024, the IRS's roughly 75,000 employees collected roughly $5T in tax revenue.   Given its role in diverting household income streams, it also has a bad reputation. Half of Americans had an "unfavorable view" of the IRS as of 2024 ( see data ). In a ranking of 16 well-known federal agencies by popularity that year, t...

Where are your children banking?

  Grant Sheehan CCUE | CCUP | CEO, NCOFCU The B reach  Between Purpose and Experience Just recently, I came across a story that has stayed with me. It wasn’t dramatic in the traditional sense. There was no scandal, no crisis, no headline-grabbing failure. In fact, it was something much quieter than that. It was simply the story of an eighteen-year-old leaving his credit union. On the surface, that might not sound remarkable. Young people move their money frequently. They open new accounts, experiment with apps, follow trends, and often make financial decisions influenced by the digital tools at their disposal. But this story was different. This young man had been a credit union member since he was a few weeks old, as many credit unions do. His mother has spent her career working inside the credit union movement as an executive. For eighteen years, his financial life was connected to a credit union. If anyone might be expected to remain a lifelong member, it wou...

Guardians Credit Union Moves Management Of Its ATM Fleet To Dolphin Debit

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla.—The $306-million  Guardians Credit Union  has turned management of its ATM fleet over to  Dolphin Debit . Minire Syla The credit union has four ATMs at branches and 10 at various select employee group sites. The decision was a big move for Guardians, which had always managed its own ATM fleet, the CU stated. “Dolphin stood out because of their experience, reliability, and the fact that they could truly take the burden off our staff,” said Chief Financial Officer Minire Syla. “Their ability to manage everything seamlessly, combined with the marketing opportunities on ATM screens, made them the best choice for us.” The credit union said it had a number of key priorities for the move, and Syla explained that while reducing the burden on staff, compliance, and cost savings were all important, what was paramount was providing “the best possible experience for our members.” “The convenience and reliability of our ATMs are crucial and outsourcing to Dolphin...

The Promise of Financial Technology. NCUA Board Member Rodney Hood

KEY WEST, Fla.–In what he said were his first remarks before a live audience in a year, NCUA Board Member Rodney Hood told a NAFCU meeting here he believes attention to financial technology (fintech) should be a priority, and that the agency will have some related regulatory guidance coming in the near future. Speaking to NAFCU’s CEOs and Senior Executives Conference here, Hood told his audience that as the pandemic subsides he wanted to focus his remarks on a single topic: “the promise of financial technology.” He related a discussion he had with the president of a small financial institution in Charlottesville, Va., that earlier this year started providing Bitcoin access at its branch locations and ATMs after customers had expressed interest. “They wanted to prove that smaller institutions could be just as innovative as the big national players,” said Hood. “Now, time will tell how this plays out. As I noted, we should view it as an experiment in customer service for now, until we ha...

Lots of Interest in Crypto, But 60% Say They Don’t Understand It, Survey Finds, Even As…

10/31/2022 CUTodayu WILTON, Conn.–Cryptocurrency investors are attracted by the opportunity for growth, but a high level of skepticism and lack of understanding remains, according to new research. In fact, 60% of respondents to the survey of more than 10,000 people admitted they don’t understand cryptocurrency The research by consumer insights provider  Toluna  surveyed people between the ages of 18 and 64 years from four regions and 19 markets to understand consumer perceptions around cryptocurrency during August 2022. The survey builds on previous waves of research carried out in December 2021 and June 2022, and examines how perceptions of cryptocurrency have continued to develop and change over time, the company said. ...