Skip to main content

NCUA Tells FICUs Crypto Trading is OK — If Big Exchanges Provide the Service


When it comes to reading between the lines of financial regulators’ advisory letters, tone matters.

Take last week’s letter from the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) which gave the federally insured credit unions (FICUs) it oversees permission to partner with digital asset providers to allow retail customers to buy, sell and trade in cryptocurrencies.

Now compare it to the one issued by Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu’s agency to the national banks and federal savings associations it regulates a month earlier.

On the surface, both said much the same thing: Financial institutions can provide cryptocurrency services (albeit with some notable differences: the OCC’s letter dealt with more back-end services, including custody services as well as holding and using dollar-pegged stablecoins for transaction settlement).

Neither was enthusiastic.

The NCUA’s letter said it “does not prohibit FICUs from establishing these relationships” — which is not as enthusiastic as “are allowed,” you’ll note — and added that it these relationship would be evaluated by the NCUA on a case-by-case basis “in the same manner as all other third-party relationships.” It went on to list factors including “exercising sound judgment and conducting the necessary due diligence, risk assessment, and planning” as well ongoing risk measurement and monitoring.

Due Diligence

The NCUA noted that its letter was in response to comments received during an ongoing “request for information” process “about the current and potential impact on FICUs, related entities, and the NCUA of activities connected to digital assets and related technologies.”

It also linked to a half dozen other guidance letters issued by the NCUA and other agencies, and said that it “recognizes that issues involving digital assets and DLT are rapidly evolving and will look to provide further clarifications and guidance, as appropriate.”

The letter went on to say that “FCUs are not limited in the types of products and services they may introduce to their members through third parties,” adding another caveat about sound judgement and due diligence.

Danger Ahead


At first glance, the OCC’s letter sounded ever-so-slightly more positive, saying the activities in question were “legally permissible.”

However, the whole sentence read that the OCC letter “clarifies that the activities addressed in those interpretive letters are legally permissible for a bank to engage in, provided the bank can demonstrate, to the satisfaction of its supervisory office, that it has controls in place to conduct the activity in a safe and sound manner.”

That emphasized “provided” speaks volumes. And the backstory is that Hsu’s predecessor proactively announced that those services were allowed — something Hsu put on hold for a review.

Then there was the accompanying press release, warning banks “not engage in the activity until it receives a non-objection from its supervisory office.”

Overall, the OCC made it clear it was not eager to see institutions dabbling in digital assets.

A Very Big Hint


Digging down, the NCUA letter has one clause that could well discourage all but the biggest crypto service providers from teaming up with federally insured credit unions — and it revolves around that “insured” part.

Noting that the federal government would not insure crypto holdings, the NCUA told FICUs that their contracts with third-party digital asset service providers “should require contracts with third parties to include provisions to indemnify the FICU for any monetary damages arising from the provision of digital asset services, including fraud.”

Those last two words are mighty big ones.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has said loudly and for years that it believes the bitcoin trading market is rife with fraud and market manipulation.

And the cost of fraud is very high in crypto. In a recent preview of its 2022 Crypto Crime Report, blockchain intelligence firm Chainalysis said fraud and theft was responsible for $7.7 billion in losses this year.

Which suggests only large firms like Coinbase, Kraken, and FTX.US that have big insurance policies or big self-insurance reserves will make their way into NCUA-regulated FICUs.

Which is likely what the agency wants.

 PYMNTS.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NCOFCU Promotes its First Class of Credit Union Professionals (CCUP)

Announcing the First Class of Certified Credit Union Professionals (CCUP) Key West, Florida – The National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions Inc. (NCOFCU) is thrilled to announce the inaugural class of Certified Credit Union Professionals (CCUP), taking a significant step towards advancing the standards of professionalism and expertise in credit union governance. This elite certification program, launched during the NCOFCU annual educational conference, provides participants with a unique opportunity to enhance their professional development, gain specialized training, and expand their network while receiving guidance from industry leaders. Over the course of two years, participants will have engaged in comprehensive sessions covering critical topics such as governance best practices, regulatory compliance, risk management, and strategic planning. "Earning the CCUP certification signifies a professional's 2-year commitment to excellence and continuous learning in cred...

NCOFCU Newsletter

The Bucket Coach is a financial advice book designed by Fire Services Credit Union, Tronto, Canada. and written exclusively for Fire Fighters It's a practical guide for household financial management, including investments, credit and mortgages, and retirement. Developed with contributions from Fire Fighters," NCOFCU Newsletter : " Kevin Connolly Chief Executive Officer    Fire Services Credit Union Phone: 416-440-1294 ext 301  Toll Free: 1-866-833-3285 E-mail:  kevin@firecreditunion.ca 1997 Avenue Rd Toronto, ON M5M 4A3 

The Fed announces quarter-point interest rate cut.

  After nine months of staying on the sidelines, the Federal Reserve on Sept. 17 announced a quarter-percentage-point cut, likely the first in a series of reductions to usher in lower borrowing rates for consumers. The rate cut – the Fed’s first since late 2024 – lowers the Fed’s benchmark interest rate to a range of 4% to 4.25%. Officials signaled the possibility of two more rate cuts this year. Typically, the Fed hikes rates or keeps them steady to tame inflation. The central bank lowers rates to juice the economy. While the Fed previously held back on rate cuts due to inflation concerns, a series of disappointing jobs reports showed a weakening labor market. While there are signs that tariffs are starting to show up in consumer prices, Powell previously said a “reasonable base case” is that tariffs spur a one-time price shift rather than a more persistent inflationary effect. "Job gains have slowed, and the unemployment rate has edged up but remains low. Inflation has moved up ...

MAP, Dolphin Debit Enter Into New Partnership

  SEATTLE–The CUSO  Member Access Processing  (MAP), a provider of Visa DPS debit, credit, ATM, and digital payment processing, said it is entering into a partnership with Dolphin Debit, the ATM and ITM management company.  “We are excited to partner with Member Access Processing,” Joe Woods, SVP-marketing & partnerships at  Dolphin Debit , said in a statement. “Our two organizations have a strong track record of providing exceptional service and solutions for our clients.   We are confident that this partnership will be a great success for both organizations and the credit unions we serve.”  Dolphin Debit noted it has partnerships with many credit union associations and operates all makes and models of ATM equipment in various branch and off-premise venues, working with over 350 financial institutions across the United States.  ‘Strengthened’ Ability “At MAP, we’re committed to helping credit unions serve their members and grow their car...

Navigating Staff & Employee Compensation

The following videos will help you to navigate the complexities of salary and benefits for your credit union staff and employees. __ ______________________________________________ Check out NCOFCU's additional features: First Responder Credit Union Academy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Blog Job Board