Skip to main content

Staying Competitive: 5 Strategic Priorities


Over the last decade, the function of a credit union branch has shifted and there have been two contributing factors: The global pandemic and expedited digital transformation.

First, the pandemic has drastically changed the way members expect to bank. At the height of the pandemic, many branches closed or reduced traffic. Members that wouldn’t typically have chosen digital banking opted for it to meet their banking needs. The shift away from branch-based services during the pandemic helped baby boomer and Gen X members adopt digital banking when they may not have otherwise.

Even without the impact of the pandemic, the transformation to digital-first processes and products has been underway for some time. This transformation has steadily been shifting the branch’s purpose away from basic transactions to more sophisticated member interactions. The pandemic merely accelerated this shift, and it is becoming vital for credit unions to embrace digital transformation to stay competitive.

Competing for Business

Over the last several years, credit union competition has evolved and expanded. Banks were once the primary competition for credit unions. Now multiple, non-traditional, digital banking options are making it increasingly difficult for credit unions to compete. Some of these branchless competitors include:

  • Fintech companies;
  • Neobanks;
  • Digital-only financial institutions;
  • Digital-first lenders and investment firms; and
  • Mobile payment platforms.

As competition increases and continues to expand into new markets, there are resources and strategies that credit unions can leverage to maximize member service and profit. Here are five growth strategies to help credit unions of all sizes maintain their competitive edge.

1. Fast track digital transformation. Some may say that digital transformation is beginning, but we argue that it’s already here. Although the pandemic highlighted the need among credit unions for digital transformation, it was already apparent that credit unions needed to adapt digitally.

Digital transformation in 2022 is being fueled by artificial intelligence. Conversational AI is becoming the norm in both business infrastructure and consumers’ daily lives. AI deploys data to replace and improve business functions and is impacting the credit union industry by improving operations, member service and digital tools. Amplifying AI technology will enhance member relationships and can help credit unions prepare for future branch disruptions.

2. Centralize member data. Your members’ data can help your credit union identify the most profitable members and predict their behaviors, as well as uncover red flags for potential risk.

Prioritize member relationships and continue to generate revenue while mitigating risk.
By Traci Mottweiler CUTimes

Centralizing member data is crucial for digitally transforming your credit union, and to enhance and streamline risk determinations, growth opportunities and member communication. Once data is centralized through a single data engine, it can then be automated to predict member behaviors, giving you a 360-degree view of your member.

These analytics can also point to increased or decreased loan risk for specific members or groups of members.

3. Mitigate lending risk. In a turbulent market, identifying and avoiding loan risk is vital for portfolio health and growth. While it is promising that the average FICO has increased since the pandemic, according to FICO, this cannot determine future payment ability or overall loan risk. Relying on the FICO score alone could lead to missed opportunities for underserved markets or additional risk for high-risk borrowers. Using member data and a proven forecasting solution can help mitigate lending risk. Additionally, consider adopting new protection solutions that can be bundled with loan products, such as unemployment protection and loan warranty, to protect both your members and your portfolio.

4. Drive alternative revenue. It is necessary, but challenging, to balance revenue growth with risk protection. Offering deposit solutions and enhancing online banking capabilities (such as remote deposit capture) growth can offset loan risks.

In addition to loan and deposit revenue, noninterest income can help drive income and maintain profits. Protection products for auto loans and mortgages can help protect members during financial crisis and uncertainty while addressing margin compressions and liquidity concerns.

5. Evaluate industry partnerships. As credit unions look for ways to streamline processes and leverage human capital, review what new solutions are available in the marketplace to outsource. Since the pandemic, many credit unions are outsourcing aspects of business that previously wouldn’t have been considered, including AI, data analytics and modeling, the call center, collections and recovery solutions. Outsourced solutions should always support your credit union’s strategic objectives.

Despite a turbulent market and shifting member expectations, the credit union mission holds fast. Prioritizing member relationships and continuing to generate revenue while mitigating risk are strong growth strategies that will help credit unions maintain their competitive edge.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Growing Your Credit Union Without Expanding Your FOM

For many firefighter and other credit union primarly serving first responders, growth often feels tied to one big decision: expanding the Field of Membership (FOM). But what if you didn’t have to? What if growth could come from within —by deepening relationships, increasing engagement, and capturing more of the financial lives of the members you already serve? The truth is: it can. But it requires a shift in strategy. Rethinking What “Growth” Really Means Most institutions define growth as adding more members. But for single-sponsor credit unions, especially those serving first responders, a more powerful definition is: Growth = more value per member Many members only use one or two products—often a checking account and maybe an auto loan. Meanwhile, larger banks capture mortgages, credit cards, and investments. The opportunity isn’t just new members. It’s: More products per member Higher balances per relationship Greater share of wallet Your Biggest Advantage: The First Responder Life...

When Vendors Price for Giants

 Grant Sheehan CCUE | CEO Opinion: When Vendors Price for Giants, They Shrink the Future of Small Credit Unions ! There’s a quiet squeeze happening in the credit union industry, and it’s not coming from regulators or competition from big banks. It’s coming from the very vendors that claim to support the ecosystem. For small credit unions, the problem is increasingly simple and factual: the tools required to compete with digital banking platforms, fraud systems, compliance software, analytics, and payments infrastructure are priced for institutions ten or even 100 times their size. The result is a market where access to essential services is determined not by mission or member need, but by asset size. This isn’t just inconvenient. It’s structurally threatening. Vendors often defend their pricing models as a reflection of complexity or scale. Larger credit unions have more users, more transactions, more integrations, so they pay more, and that seems fair on the surface. But t...

How's Your Posture?

      April Blog   How's Your Posture?   Scenario Planning Is Dead! Long Live Strategic Posture. by That One Consultant You Hired and Then Ignored   Somewhere in your credi...

Fed still holds off on rate increase | 2015-07-30 | CUNA News

  WASHINGTON (7/30/15)--Citing “moderate” economic expansion, the Federal Open Market Committee continues to do “a balancing act,” said CUNA Senior Economist Perc Pineda. The Federal Reserve’s monetary policy-making body completed its meeting Wednesday without edging up the federal funds interest rate. Fed Chair Janet Yellen has said the committee will opt for an interest-rate increase sometime this fall. The July meeting, however, was not the time. “The Federal Reserve continues to do a balancing act: the U.S. economy is not in a recession and definitely not overheating,” Pineda told News Now . “Changes in monetary policy after all are meant to influence an underperforming or an overheating economy.” Household spending growth has been moderate, and housing has shown additional improvement, the committee said. Labor conditions continue to improve with declining unemployment and solid job gains. Inflation is anticipated to remain near its recent low level in the near term,...

What to Know About EV Lending

  By Ray Birch WEST WINDSOR TOWNSHIP, N.J.—There are a couple of important facts credit unions must keep in mind as they increasingly make loans for electric vehicles (EVs). The first is that while EVs are perceived to be more economical than internal combustion engine (ICE)-powered vehicles, one new report suggests that while electric vehicles are cheaper to operate, the overall savings may not be as significant as many people think. Moreover, as EVs become the dominant form of transportation, prices for charging—even at home—will begin to rise just like gas prices, one automotive industry expert is predicting. Sumit Chauhan, co- founder and COO at Cerebrum X, which provides AI-driven automotive data services and a management platform, s...

Don't say NO to your members anymore!

Does the following scenario occur at your credit union? If it does, we have a solution for you! A member comes in into your credit union and wants to know if you will loan them a couple of hundred thousand $$$ to buy a building, or can you loan him some seed money to start a new business or purchase equipment for the company they currently own, and you say,  “the credit union doesn't do those kinds of loans”.  Does this sound familiar? How many times do you and your staff say NO and literally tell a member to  “go down the street or go somewhere else” ?  Well, now, you have another option.   CU First Responders Finance (CUFR) CU First Responders Finance, LLC (CUFR)  is a partnership between the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions, Inc.   (NCOFCU) , and Biz Lending & Insurance Center, Inc. to provide business lending origination programs to NCOFCU member credit unions. CUFR  will provide you with a turnkey operati...

TSA PreCheck Reminder

If you have not done this, I highly recommend you do! With plenty of summer days left to go, the Transportation Security Administration is continuing its PreCheck push. Earlier this year the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) announced that more than 1 million travelers had registered for its time-saving PreCheck program. Now, as the summer goes into full swing, the agency is pushing to raise that number even higher with a new campaign to draw more on-the-go Americans. For the uninitiated, the TSA’s PreCheck program allows vetted travelers to move more quickly through separate security screening lines and to skip standard protocols, including removing belts and laptops during preflight security checks. To raise awareness of the program, the TSA will be sharing two new ads, one of which can be seen below, that explain the basic benefits of signing up.So if you still have some summer traveling on the books or perhaps to the NCOFCU Annual Meeting and Exposition in Nashvi...

NCOFCU Promotes its First Class of Credit Union Professionals (CCUP)

Announcing the First Class of Certified Credit Union Professionals (CCUP) Key West, Florida – The National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions Inc. (NCOFCU) is thrilled to announce the inaugural class of Certified Credit Union Professionals (CCUP), taking a significant step towards advancing the standards of professionalism and expertise in credit union governance. This elite certification program, launched during the NCOFCU annual educational conference, provides participants with a unique opportunity to enhance their professional development, gain specialized training, and expand their network while receiving guidance from industry leaders. Over the course of two years, participants will have engaged in comprehensive sessions covering critical topics such as governance best practices, regulatory compliance, risk management, and strategic planning. "Earning the CCUP certification signifies a professional's 2-year commitment to excellence and continuous learning in cred...

IRS Reporting Proposal Scaled Back, but Still 'Flawed'

On Tuesday, Senate Democrats distributed an update to the controversial IRS reporting requirements that the credit union industry has been very vocally opposed to since it was unveiled in late June. According to the updated proposal rolled out Tuesday, it would require financial institutions to report inflows and outflows of personal and business accounts, as well as transfers between accounts of the same owner, if it is more than $10,000 per year. The proposal floating around for the past four months had the threshold at $600 per year. The requirements do not apply to payroll deposits for wages or to those receiving Social Security benefits. In response to the updated IRS reporting proposal, NAFCU President/CEO Dan Berger said, “It has become abundantly clear that Americans oppose the IRS obtaining additional information on their financial accounts. The updated plan is nothing more than window dressing in an attempt to shore up support for a flawed proposal. Instead of creating financ...

2 Historical Moments: CUNA Mutual Officially Changes Name Today, As Union Also Calls Strike

MADISON, Wis.–One of the most iconic names in credit unions and credit union history in the U.S. will officially change today when CUNA Mutual Group begins operating under the TruStage brand across the enterprise. All enterprise, business-to-business and consumer brands are now unified under the single brand name of TruStage, which the company has been using for some of its products for a number of years. The new brand is being introduced at the same time approximately 450 employees represented by Office & Professional Employees Local 39 have gone on strike. It is the first strike in the company and the union's history. As CUToday.info has been reporting, the company and the union have been at an impasse since February of 2022, when t...