Skip to main content

NCUA Opens Door to Crypto for Credit Unions

The NCUA has told credit unions they can use the technology behind cryptocurrency as long as they follow NCUA principles to ensure compliance with existing regulations and don’t create undue risk.

NCUA Chairman Todd Harper’s four-page letter sent Thursday to federally insured credit unions said the NCUA does not prohibit credit unions from employing distributed ledger technology (DLT), which is used to support cryptocurrencies, “if it is deployed for permissible activities and in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations, including applicable state laws or state supervisory authority requirements.”

“As with the development of any new product or service when deploying a platform, product or service using DLT as part of the underlying technology, credit unions should find an appropriate balance between the opportunities and the risks,” Harper wrote.

“This letter also signals to the broader financial and technology communities that credit unions are a market to consider when designing products, considering partnerships or making investments,” he wrote.

Todd Harper Todd Harper (Source: NCUA)

Harper’s letter followed a similar form as one in December, in which he said the NCUA would allow credit unions to hire third-party vendors for cryptocurrency as long as they abided by the same NCUA safety and soundness principles applied in other vendor relationships.

NAFCU had asked for guidance on digital assets in a letter sent to the NCUA last September. Greg Mesack, NAFCU’s SVP of government affairs, thanked the NCUA for “for reducing regulatory uncertainties around digital assets.”

“There is without a doubt a need for additional guidance from regulators on how credit unions can better adopt digital assets and emerging financial technologies,” Mesack said.

“We appreciate that the NCUA heeded our call to adopt a form-agnostic approach to assessing how credit unions use digital assets and related technologies,” he said. “We will continue to articulate the credit union industry’s perspective on this topic and encourage the NCUA to continue building a sound digital assets regulatory framework.”

Ryan Donovan, CUNA’s EVP and chief advocacy officer, also thanked the NCUA for the guidance on distributed ledger technologies, “an issue CUNA has repeatedly asked the agency to address.”

Ryan Donovan Ryan Donovan

“Many questions will likely persist regarding credit unions’ ability to participate in the digital currency space,” Donovan said. “We look forward to more detailed guidance from (the) NCUA on these issues as credit unions continue to explore the benefits of these technologies for their membership.”

The most common distributed ledger technology is Blockchain, which supports Bitcoin and Ethereum. Both cryptocurrencies have traded wildly, especially since the start of 2021. Their values rose three- to four-fold from January to November 2021, then took a roller-coaster plunge that accelerated in April, wiping out all of Bitcoin’s gains since 2021 and nearly all of Ethereum’s by Thursday.

Harper’s letter started with the statement that the NCUA “supports initiatives by federally insured credit unions to better serve their members.”

“The rapid emergence of financial technology is creating opportunities for credit unions to increase the speed of service, improve security, and expand products and services,” Harper wrote. “In this spirit, the board is exploring how the agency can provide clarity around expectations regarding financial technology adoption to not impede safe, fair, and responsible federally insured credit union engagement.”

“As with the internet at its inception, the NCUA recognizes that new technologies may transform how credit unions perform traditional financial operations and services,” Harper wrote. “While DLT is maturing, the NCUA recognizes that cases for implementation may expand rapidly as the technology becomes more widespread and credit unions become more familiar with it.”

The NCUA listed several steps credit unions should take “at a minimum.” They included:

  • The credit union’s board of directors is notified of advancements in the underlying technology, the purposes of the technology, and how using DLT aligns with the credit union’s strategic planning objectives and approved risk tolerances.
  • Credit union staff and third parties using and managing the technology are complying with applicable laws and regulations and acting in a safe and sound manner.
  • Effective risk-management practices are followed to identify, assess and mitigate risks associated with DLT and the specific activities for which it will be deployed.
  • Risk assessment and audit functions can validate and attest to the effectiveness of risk mitigation practices in accordance with internal policy and industry leading practices.
  • Credit unions must identify, assess and mitigate risks associated with DLT.

Jim DuPlessis
CUTimes

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

'Tis the season for fraud! Teller questions if member fraud is suspected.

  When a credit union employee suspects a member may be subject to fraud, they should initiate a careful conversation focusing on the nature of the transaction and external influences. The goal is to help the member identify red flags without the employee asking for sensitive personal information that the credit union should already have on file.  Initial Verification Questions    .pdf Before discussing the specifics of the suspicious activity, the employee should confirm the member's identity in accordance with established internal protocols.  Questions About the Transaction/Activity If the member confirms they are conducting a suspicious transaction (e.g., a large wire transfer or purchase of gift cards ), the employee should ask questions to help the member pause and think critically:  "What is the purpose of this transaction?" "Do you personally know the person or business you are sending money to?" "Have you ever met the...

Have a Safe and Happy Thanksgiving!

    Thanksgiving, is a day when we pause to give thanks for what we have! www. NCOFCU .org   Have a Safe a...

Hybrid? Work from Home? Office? The Debate Over The Ideal Work Environment Continues in CUs

 The Still-to-be-Answered Question About Work By Ray Birch MADISON, Wis.—With several years’ experience now under their belts, what has turned out to be the most productive work structure for credit unions in the wake of the pandemic—return to office, work from home, hybrid? It’s a challenging question, one compounded by the fact many CUs lack objective metrics for measurement, according to one person. “As we all know, credit unions first jumped to remote work and then things came back a bit as they tried to create a work environment that as closely as possible reflected ‘normal,’” explained Lesley Sears, VP of consulting services at CUES. Sears pointed out when credit unions shut down at the b...

Are You Holding Your Credit Union Back? A Directors’ Guide to Stepping Up Your Game & Staying Relevant

These are harder questions ...     May Blog - Asking Some Harder Questions ...

Loan Growth Part 3

MADISON, Wis.–Credit union loan balances rose 1.1% in February, faster than the 0.2% reported in February 2021, even as membership growth slowed significantly during the first two months of 2022, according to data released as part of CUNA Mutual’s April Trends Report. The Report, which is based on data through February, showed overall loan growth was 9.6% during the last 12 months. What is actually happening below the surface? According to the Trends Report, consistent with the trend line the analysis shows large credit unions reported significantly faster loan growth in 2021 as compared to smaller credit unions. Credit unions with assets greater than $1 billion reported loan growth of 8.4% compared to credit unions with assets less than $20 million, reporting loan growth of 0.9%. Here's a look at how credit unions performed by category, according to the newest Trends Report” ...

Sunday reading - What's the story behind Thanksgiving?

What's the story behind Thanksgiving? While European settlers in North America had long observed days of thanks, prayer, and reflection, the “ first Thanksgiving ” most often refers to a 1621 meal between the Pilgrims and the native Wampanoag people.   In 1863, Abraham Lincoln declared a national Thanksgiving Day on the final Thursday of November to be celebrated each year. A large meal shared with loved ones is the centerpiece of most Thanksgiving celebrations, where the average gathering size is seven and most people consume 3,150-4,500 calories .   What began as a neighborly meal to celebrate a successful harvest has transformed into an annual economic and cultural powerhouse: The day before Thanksgiving is one of the busiest days of the year for air travel as Americans prepare to eat upward of 40 million turkeys  and 80 million pounds of cranberries. ... Read what else we  learned about the holiday here . ...

Fed cuts interest rates for the second time this year

The Federal Reserve on Wednesday lowered interest rates for the second time this year in a continued bid to prevent unemployment from surging. Fed officials voted for another quarter-point rate cut, lowering their benchmark lending rate to a range between 3.75% and 4%, the lowest in three years. It is the first time since the Fed’s rate-setting committee was established in the 1930s that officials have set monetary policy while lacking an entire month of crucial government employment data due to a government shutdown. ____________________________________ Check out NCOFCU's additional features: First Responder Credit Union Academy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Blog Job Board

Trump Administration Reverses Course, Restores CDFI Fund Staff In Major Win for Credit Unions

WASHINGTON—In a sharp reversal of the Trump Administration’s earlier move, the mass reduction-in-force (RIF) notices issued to all employees of the CDFI Fund last month have been rescinded, according to internal emails reviewed by Punchbowl News. The notices had threatened terminations in December as part of a broader effort by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) under Director Russ Vought to pressure congressional Democrats to drop their objections in the budget-funding fight. For the credit-union movement, the signal is loud and clear: critical community-development infrastructure may yet be preserved, sources stated. “Reinstating the entire CDFI Fund staff is an essential and welcome step toward restoring a program that has proven itself indispensable to underserved and military communities,” said DCUC Chief Advocacy Officer Jaso Stverak. “The CDFI Fund isn’t just another federal initiative—it is a lifeline for servicemembers, veterans, and low-income families who rely on miss...

Not Your Mother’s Credit Union

“Stablecoins aren’t a speculative play. They’re the next evolution of payments — and a chance for credit unions to lead, not lag. It starts with connecting members to DLT rails - the digital wallet. Without that, nothing else can happen. It’s just a new payment rail - embrace it or lose the relationship. It’s that simple.” While ‘ stablecoins ’ were the prevailing buzzword across Money20/20 this year, the credit union industry had a significant presence. Small financial institutions have staked a place in the future of payments. Credit unions  received a significant boost this summer with the enactment of the stablecoin bill into law. The Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins Act authorizes subsidiaries of federally insured credit unions, such as credit union service organizations, to become issuers. Not Your Mother’s Credit Union A Money20/20  fireside chat  with the regulator for credit unions that I moderated focused on the rulemaking task a...

A Preview of What Call Reports Are Likely to Reveal

By Ray Birch LAKE FOREST, Ill.—An early analysis of what call reports are likely to show this year when it comes to overdraft revenue indicates credit unions should be prepared for increased scrutiny and criticism from legislators, the media, consumer groups and, of course, the banking industry. All credit unions of more than $1 billion in assets—438 out of 4,702 CUs—will need for the first time ever to report their overdraft revenue separately this year. And when they do, data from the latest Moebs $ervices OD survey—which is based on a company poll in January of FIs’ 2023 year-end data—indicates the attention being paid to how credit unions price overdrafts and the income generated is going to heat up, according to Michael Moebs, economist and chairman of Moebs $ervices. ...