Skip to main content

ATM Pooling: Solving the ATM Puzzle for Credit Unions


At its inception over 50 years ago, the ATM fired the starting gun for the self-service banking culture and quickly gained steam as a crucial touchpoint that freed account holders from the shackles of business hours and banking at a single branch. Today, a myriad of factors including trends accelerated by a global pandemic, social/political pressures, and rapidly advancing ATM technology are again shifting self-service expectations and changing the framework of the traditional ATM network.

For credit unions, the recent changes surrounding the ATM has created a quandary in regard to their ATM network strategy. On one hand, cash usage decline and scares of a “cashless society” have put a microscope on escalating ATM costs, usage, and regulatory compliance for credit unions, and understandably so. But, simultaneously, access to cash remains relevant, accounting for roughly 20% of all transactions in the U.S., and the pressure for credit unions to serve even the smallest of communities remains constant. All while new ATM technologies continue to add functionality and deeper account access for consumers, giving way to hybrid or fully self-service branch models.

So, to sum it up - If you reduce or stop investment into your ATM fleet, you risk a critical self-service channel becoming obsolete and your institution failing to effectively serve your members and community, likely costing you accounts and goodwill. Conversely, if you continue to invest into your ATM fleet to meet the rising demand for self-service, the cost is high and the return is low, in other words, putting more capital into a loss leader. So, where do we go from here?

Shared Infrastructure:

Across the globe, credit unions faced with this same dilemma have turned to a solution commonly referred to as “ATM Pooling”, a strategy that delivers operational cost savings while expanding the ATM footprint and simplifying the management and security of the ATM channel as a whole.

By definition, ATM pooling involves transferring ATM ownership and operational responsibility to an expert third-party, resulting in significant cost reduction for the individual financial institution, and allowing them to continue serving consumers in locations where low demand would otherwise render an ATM uneconomical.

Prime examples of the success of this strategy are the Geldmaat Network in the Netherlands, and Batopin in Belgium. In both cases, several of the country’s largest banks have joined forces through shared ATM infrastructure aimed at optimizing the network and providing a safe and efficient service to their account holders. In short, these credit unions are less attached to the headache and heartache of ATM ownership and operations, and more interested in the efficiency and performance of the shared infrastructure.

The U.S. ATM Pooling Blueprint:

In the U.S., ATM pooling might not yet be on the radar of our country’s largest credit unions as it is in Europe, but organizations such as credit union associations, chapters, leagues, and other member-based advocate programs create opportunity in the ATM pooling space at the state and regional level. With widespread reach and member bases typically consisting of hundreds of credit unions, opening a shared ATM infrastructure program would create significant cost savings, network optimization, and operational efficiencies for participating credit unions, while passing along convenience to their account holders.

Dolphin Debit (Euronet Worldwide’s North American ATM Services Division) has been “pooling” ATMs since 2005. Currently, the Dolphin ATM Alliance consists of 2,000+ ATMs spread throughout the U.S. With a blueprint already in place, this is a shared infrastructure service model that is poised to rival the ATM pooling initiatives of our foreign banking colleagues.

Service models like the Dolphin ATM Alliance combine the operational simplicity and cost cutting elements of a pure play end-to-end ATM outsourcing solution with the “pooling” effect of shared ATM infrastructure. A combination that effectively solves the ATM puzzle for credit unions: less capital investment into the ATM fleet, streamlined ATM operations, an expanded ATM footprint, and seamless adaptation to everchanging regulatory compliance requirements and rapidly advancing ATM technology.

Joe Woods, CUDE | SVP, Marketing & Partnerships

Dolphin Debit Access, LLC | 1340 Rayford Park Rd., Spring, TX 77386

(M) 614-378-0367

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NCOFCU - "Video Mini's" The Federal Reserve

The Federal Reserve, often referred to as the Fed, is the central banking system of the United States. Established in 1913 by the Federal Reserve Act, the Federal Reserve serves several crucial functions in the U.S. economy. Here are the main aspects of the Federal Reserve:  Visit NCOFCU's YouTube channel for more. "Video Mini's" The NCOFCU "Video Minis" are a series of concise 2-3 minute video presentations designed to deliver valuable insights and knowledge on key topics relevant to credit unions. Each video focuses on a specific subject, providing viewers with essential information in a brief and engaging format. These mini-presentations cover a range of subjects. Perfect for busy professionals seeking quick yet impactful content, the Video Minis make it easy to stay informed and enhance your credit union's operations and member services. Join us in exploring these informative and dynamic learning opportunities!

Credit Unions Must Focus On Treasury Rates to Avoid Liquidity Crunch In 2025

By Ray Birch LAKE FOREST, Ill.—Credit unions seeking to avoid a liquidity crunch this year must pay attention to one key fact: deposit rates are now a function of Treasury rates. To protect and gain deposits, CUs must price deposit services with high rates to match government rates, explained Michael Moebs, economist and chair of Moebs $ervices (see graph showing average T-bond rates are all over 4%.) “The U.S Treasury is a competitor you can no longer avoid,” Moebs said. “Rates for transaction accounts, like interest checking and savings, need to be markedly higher for 20% of consumers who hold 80% of the balances for these services.” In March 2023, the Federal Reserve, not the FDIC, bailed out Silicon Valley Bank, guaranteeing all deposits with 90% exceeding the maximum FDIC insurance limits, Moebs pointed out. “Deposit insurance established in June 1933 was forever transformed. Sure, deposit insurance still exists, but is viewed by consumers and small businesses to have a new partne...

President Trump is leading the way toward reduced check usage by phasing out paper checks for government payments.

WASHINGTON—A new  executive order  from President Donald Trump bans paper checks as a form of payment for the federal government. The order was signed noting that Treasury checks are often reported stolen, and face other issues. The order also notes that payments made  to  the federal government are also modernizing. “Check fraud is a perennial concern for the banking industry, growing in recent years – reports doubled from 2021 to 2022. Target stores announced last year that they would stop accepting paper checks,” the Independent Community Bankers of America pointed out. “It's a great sign that the government is leading the way toward reduced check usage by phasing out paper checks for government payments,” said ICBA payments expert Scott Anchin, noting that consumers and financial institutions should maintain the ability to determine appropriate payment mechanisms for specific cases.  ABA President and CEO Rob Nichols said his organization welcomes President ...

5 ways credit unions can future-proof their technology for long-term success

Technology is evolving at lightning speed. If credit unions want to stay relevant and serve their members like rockstars, it’s time to think ahead. While this may sound daunting, it’s actually a thrilling time to be in the financial services business—especially as a credit union. By diving into cloud-based banking, embracing AI to handle manual, repetitive tasks, and doubling down on data security, credit unions can improve their members’ lives, and set themselves up for long-term success. Below are five ways credit unions stay ahead of the competition, no matter what comes next. 1. Embracing cloud-based banking When it comes to the future, transitioning to a cloud-based banking platform is one of the most significant steps a credit union can take, especially in terms of scalability and flexibility. Cloud platforms provide the infrastructure necessary for credit unions to efficiently manage operations, reduce IT costs, and respond quickly to market changes. As if all that wasn’t enough...

Will Fed be Watching ‘That ’70s Show,’ Economy Version? Debate is On

WASHINGTON–When the Fed opted not to raise rates last his week after expressing concerns over lingering inflation—while also stating it sees strength in the economy—there is another word it “dreads” but also didn’t mention, according to a new report. That word? Stagflation, an “an economic curse that is hard to escape.” Stagflation is the term used for a combination of high inflation, stagnant economic growth, and high unemployment. “Eager to soothe worried investors, businesses and consumers, the Fed urged caution about getting too worked up about its forecast, noting that inflation caused by tariffs may not be long lasting,” said CNN in an analysis released after the Fed adjourned this week. “Nevertheless, there’s no cocktail a central banker hates more than high unemployment mixed with high inflation.” Wall Street Gets Jitters The report noted that Wall Street has already begun to sound the alarm about stagflation, Fed Chair Jerome Powell has remained relatively “sanguine.”  “Bu...