Apple’s new savings account for Apple Card should be a “wake-up call” for credit unions

12/08/2022 CUToday

By Ray Birch

SAN CARLOS, Calif.—Apple’s new savings account for Apple Card should be a “wake-up call” for credit unions, says one analyst, who is urging CUs to respond in the right way or risk losing deposits and member relationships.

Richard Crone, principal of Crone Consulting LLC, told CUToday.info that more credit unions need to support Apple Wallet—as well as all the other so-called “pay,” while additionally removing their and savings account withdrawal limits.

“Credit unions by definition are supposed to have better savings rates because they’re member-owned and not-for-profit and are chartered to pass along the higher yields to their membership,” said Crone. “But in order to compete with Apple Savings, with Goldman Sachs, they’ll have to do more than match or surpass Goldman’s high-yield rates, they’ll have to support Apple Wallet and offer a savings account without any transaction limits or fees, which most credit unions do not do.”

Apple recently announced a new savings account for Apple Card that will allow users to save via an Apple Cash account while also building rewards via a high-yield savings account from Goldman Sachs.

Daily Cash is the 3% cash back all Apple Cardholders receive on purchases.

According to Apple.com, in the coming months, Apple Card users will be able to open the new high-yield Savings account and have their Daily Cash automatically deposited into it — with no fees, no minimum deposits, and no minimum balance requirements. Soon, users will also be able to spend, send, and save Daily Cash directly from Wallet, Apple.com reported.

‘Favorite Benefits’

“Savings enables Apple Card users to grow their daily cash rewards over time, while also saving for the future,” Jennifer Bailey, Apple’s vice president of Apple Pay and Apple Wallet, told Apple.com. “Savings delivers even more value to users’ favorite Apple Card benefit — daily cash — while offering another easy-to-use tool designed to help users lead healthier financial lives.”

Once users set up their savings account, all future Daily Cash received will be automatically deposited into it, or they can choose to continue to have it added to an Apple Cash card in Wallet. Users can change their daily cash destination at any time, Apple.com noted.

“When you talk to credit unions, you find that nearly all still impose transaction limits on savings accounts, even though the Federal Reserve Bank eliminated the six transactions per month limit on savings accounts in April 2020 in their pandemic updates to Regulation D, driven by making money more accessible during the lockdowns,” Crone explained. “There are big strategic implications here for credit unions.”

‘Greater Utility’

Richard Crone

Crone said the success of the new Apple Card venture is the ability to actually provide full utility, not only for credit but for prepaid debit, general-purpose reloadable cards.

“The challenger banks and neo banks all use general purpose, reloadable cards as checking,” said Crone. “This extends greater utility to the consumer, but more importantly, it's a platform for adding new services. And this is the first one that Apple is adding—meaning if you earn a cash reward you can open a savings account and that savings account will pay high-yield interest on your balances that you earn from making purchases with the Apple Card.

“So, you can see that it's the full spectrum,” he continued. “They not only allow you to make purchases giving you immediate access to your cash rewards, on top of that you hold the money in a savings account whereas you earn those rewards you can earn interest. In fact, they allow you to make additional deposits to that savings account and use it as a cash management account.”

‘Wake-Up Call’

But according to Crone, what is an even larger concern than losing deposits to a new Apple savings account that functions like checking is the convenience with which the account can be opened.

“That account is opened instantly, and they now have a relationship with that customer,” said Crone. “The enrollment today isn't occurring at branches. The enrollment isn't occurring among select employer groups. And the enrollment certainly isn't happening at substance over the phone. The enrollment is happening online. This should be a wake-up call for credit unions on where to increase enrollment. It’s not at a branch. It’s not on the phone. It’s not through a SEG.”

To be effective at enrolling consumers via online platforms, Crone believes credit unions must “redefine” their fields of membership.

“The field of membership should not be based on where that consumer is, the common bond of a meta user is the group,” explained Crone. “So, that could mean Uber drivers, or TikTok users or… Credit unions are stuck in the old definition of the field of membership and that has to change.”

The ’New Transaction Accounts'

What also has to change are the rules around credit union's savings accounts, emphasized Crone.

“Savings accounts are becoming the new transaction accounts, competing with checking,” Crone explained. “But, as I said, the Federal Reserve in April of 2020 lifted the withdrawal restrictions on savings accounts. What Apple is doing here is pushing the edge of that the redefinition of what a savings account is. They can provide immediate access and utility to the savings account through Apple Pay and you can now pay anywhere, and you can now deposit as much as you want anytime, or withdrawal funds then. It essentially has all the utility of a checking account.”

Credit unions need to follow suit with savings design, and also make debit and credit products available through the “pays,” said Crone.

“They need to do this, and address field of membership, if they want to compete for the next wave of young members. They need to do this to have a fighting chance,” he said.

Comments

The Skills Board Chairs Need Now: Leading Through Complexity, Not Control

NCOFCU Podcast Grant Sheehan CCUE | CCUP | CEO-NCOFCU The role of the board chair has quietly—but fundamentally—changed. A decade ago, success was defined by experience, authority, and strategic judgment. Today, those traits are still relevant—but no longer sufficient. The modern board chair operates in a world shaped by competing stakeholder demands, technological disruption, geopolitical uncertainty, and increasing scrutiny. What emerges is a role that is less about control—and more about navigating complexity. Below are the core capabilities that now define effective board leadership. 1. From Authority to Orchestration The most important shift is conceptual. Board chairs are no longer expected to be the smartest voice in the room. Instead, they are expected to make the room smarter . This requires the ability to: Synthesize large volumes of information Reconcile conflicting perspectives Facilitate high-quality dialogue Traditional strengths like executive experience matter les...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

It All Starts in the Boardroom

It all starts in the boardroom—but the consequences are felt far beyond it. When Governance Breaks Down, Members Pay the Price Credit unions are built on a simple but powerful idea: they are owned by their members. Unlike traditional banks, where shareholders drive decisions, credit unions are meant to operate democratically—guided by a volunteer board elected by the very people they serve. But that model only works when participation exists. A governance breakdown happens when the people elected to oversee an institution stop truly representing the people who own it. In credit unions, this breakdown doesn’t usually come from scandal or sudden failure. It happens quietly, over time—through disengagement. The Root of the Problem: Low Engagement Most credit union members don’t vote. Board election turnout is typically in the low single digits. In some cases, it’s barely measurable. That means a very small percentage of the membership is effectively deciding who governs an institution th...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

On Stablecoins, NCUA Has Opportunity to Strike Right Balance and Get it Right

By Grant Sheehan As digital payments continue to evolve, the National Credit Union Administration’s (NCUA) efforts to establish a regulatory framework for stablecoins mark an important step forward. For credit unions, especially those serving mission-driven communities like firefighters and first responders, access to emerging financial technologies is not just an opportunity but a necessity to remain competitive and relevant. The National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions (NCOFCU) appreciates the thoughtful input provided by both America’s Credit Unions and the Defense Credit Union Council (DCUC) on the NCUA’s proposed stablecoin framework. We find strong merit in the recommendations of both organizations and believe their combined perspectives offer a constructive roadmap for getting this right. Important First Phase, But… At its core, the proposal represents an important first phase in implementing the stablecoin provisions of the GENIUS Act. Establishing a...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Sunday Reading - Why the IRS is necessary

'Taxman' Why the IRS is necessary The Internal Revenue Service, or IRS, is a division of the US Treasury Department created in 1862 that enforces the Internal Revenue Code —Title 26 of the US Code, a compilation of federal statutes—and, effectively, oversees tax collection. In 2024, the IRS's roughly 75,000 employees collected roughly $5T in tax revenue. Given its role in diverting household income streams, it also has a bad reputation. Half of Americans had an "unfavorable view" of the IRS as of 2024 ( see data ). In a ranking of 16 well-known federal agencies by popularity that year, t...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

It's Financial Literacy Month

April is Financial Literacy Month—a time dedicated to empowering individuals and families with the knowledge and tools needed to make informed financial decisions. Whether you're budgeting, saving, managing debt, or planning for the future, improving your financial literacy can have a lasting impact on your well-being. We invite you to explore our Consumer Education website, where you'll find helpful resources, tips, and guidance to support your financial journey. If you find it valuable, please share it with your family and friends—because financial knowledge is even more powerful when it’s shared. https://www.ncofcu.org/financial-literacy ================================================= Remember, you're not alone with NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional features: Annual Conference First Responder Credit Union Academy Financial Literacy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Advocacy

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Growing Use of Stablecoins Could Reshape How FIs Manage Liquidity, Allocate Assets, NY Fed Report Suggests

NEW YORK — The growing use of stablecoins tied to the U.S. dollar could reshape how banks manage liquidity and allocate assets, potentially leading institutions that support the digital tokens to hold more reserves and make fewer loans, according to a new study from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York . The paper, titled “ Stablecoin Disintermediation ,” was authored by economists Michael Junho Lee and Donny Tou and examines how stablecoin activity affects the balance sheets and liquidity management of banks that partner with stablecoin issuers. The researchers found that while stablecoins rely on traditional banks to function, the relationships can alter the liquidity demands placed on those institutions. Banks serving stablecoin issuers tend to hold larger reserve balances and reduce the share of assets devoted to lending, shifting toward a more reserve-heavy banking model. Focus of Study The study focused on developments following the March 2023 collapse of...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

The Federal Open Market Committee Up's Rates

WASHINGTON–As expected the Federal Open Market Committee at its meeting today moved to increase rates by a quarter-point to a range of 1.25% to 1.50%. In a statement accompanying the announcement, the Federal Reserve said data from November indicate the labor market has continued to strengthen and that economic activity has been rising at a solid rate. “Averaging through hurricane-related fluctuations, job gains have been solid, and the unemployment rate declined further,” the Fed said. “Household spending has been expanding at a moderate rate, and growth in business fixed investment has picked up in recent quarters. On a 12-month basis, both overall inflation and inflation for items other than food and energy have declined this year and are running below 2%. Market-based measures of inflation compensation remain low; survey-based measures of longer-term inflation expectations are little changed, on balance.” The Committee said it continues to expect that, with gradual...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Why is NCUA Overlooking the Biggest Fee of All?

By Frank J. Diekmann NCUA has made a priority out of the F word in 2024—fees--announcing a special focus on NSF and OD fees this year. And yet the agency seems to have little interest in the biggest and most egregious fee of all—the “merger” fee that comes when net worth isn’t returned to the people whose money it is in the first place, and it instead goes to insiders—often in amounts a multitude larger than any bounced check fee. It's sadly ironic that NCUA seems bothered by fees members opt into, but not by a merger fee they don’t seem able to opt out of. The merger fee is a hidden-in-plain-sight cost to members that is so brazen and increasingly occurring it has entered that dangerous territory of almost being taken for granted, wi...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Preparing Credit Unions for a Transformative Decade Ahead

CUs must meet their current members' needs, anticipate their future needs and seek out a new generation. By Pam Cohen | June 03, 2024 at 09:00 AM Credit/AdobeStock As we navigate through an era of rapid change and economic uncertainty, credit unions stand at a critical juncture. The future beckons with both challenges and unprecedented opportunities, but by embracing innovation and focusing on member-focused services, credit unions can remain relevant and impactful in a space where consumers are quick to embrace brands with the most marketing dollars. As an industry we need to take a look at our current members, meet their needs, anticipate their future needs and seek out a new generation of members. As we look to the needs of members in the next decade, the success of credit unions hinges on the ability to merge technological advancements with personalized service. You don't need me to tell you that members want ...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Where are your children banking?

Grant Sheehan CCUE | CCUP | CEO, NCOFCU The B reach Between Purpose and Experience Just recently, I came across a story that has stayed with me. It wasn’t dramatic in the traditional sense. There was no scandal, no crisis, no headline-grabbing failure. In fact, it was something much quieter than that. It was simply the story of an eighteen-year-old leaving his credit union. On the surface, that might not sound remarkable. Young people move their money frequently. They open new accounts, experiment with apps, follow trends, and often make financial decisions influenced by the digital tools at their disposal. But this story was different. This young man had been a credit union member since he was a few weeks old, as many credit unions do. His mother has spent her career working inside the credit union movement as an executive. For eighteen years, his financial life was connected to a credit union. If anyone might be expected to remain a lifelong member, it wou...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

First-responder Credit Union Newsroom

Search This Blog