Skip to main content

If NY's AG Is Right, Then We Are All Doing Something Seriously Wrong

Credit unions in New York State could be on the hook for billions of dollars in additional unauthorized transfer costs.

By Henry Meier, Esq. | April 08, 2024 at 12:43 PMPile of court files with a gavel sitting on top Credit/Shutterstock

There's been a lot of national news lately about pending court cases in New York City, but you may not have heard about the one that is important for credit unions on a national level.

In January, New York Attorney General Letitia James filed a lawsuit generally alleging that CitiBank was engaging in illegal and deceptive practices by refusing to extend protections of the Electronic Funds Transfer Act (EFTA) to consumers victimized by unauthorized wire transfers. See People of the State of New York v. CitiBank, S.D.N.Y., Case No. 24 Civ. 0659).

Late last week, CitiBank filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. It makes a compelling argument that the AG's argument amounts to a radical reinterpretation of existing law that would expose financial institutions to billions of dollars in losses and make the existing framework for wire transfers obsolete overnight. Although this decision would only apply to the Second Circuit, you don't have to be Nostradamus to see that it would end up being litigated across the country.

In 1978, Congress passed the EFTA. Most importantly, the statute caps liability for unauthorized transfers involving a consumer account. However, even as it passed the law, Congress created a distinction between wire transfers, which are generally transfers using the Fed wire system and similar networks, and transactions covered by the EFTA. This distinction was absolutely critical since financial institutions did not want to be on the hook for the huge amount of money facilitated by the Fed on a daily basis. See 15 USC §1693a(7)(B).

Article 4A of the UCC, which was adopted in the 1990s, was drafted, in part, to further delineate the distinction between wire transfers and EFTA protections. Under Article 4A, financial institutions are not subject to strict liability for unauthorized fund transfers. They must, however, adopt procedures agreed to by customers designed to confirm that wire transfer requests are authorized. There is no strict liability for unauthorized transfers. Today, this distinction is so well established that virtually every account agreement contains separate sections for wire transfers and EFTA disclosures.

This background explains why the AG's argument is so important. The AG's argument is that financial institutions interpret the EFTA exemptions too broadly. The AG argues that while a wire transfer between banks using the Fed system is not subject to EFTA protections, the subsequent transfer of that money by the receiving bank into a consumer's account is covered.

For this and other reasons, I am cautiously optimistic that the AG's argument is a bridge too far and will be rejected. If it is not, credit unions in New York State will be on the hook for billions of dollars in additional unauthorized transfer costs and credit unions across the country will have to deal with similar lawsuits sprouting up in a courthouse near them sooner than later.

In fairness to the AG, however, the more I delve into issues relating to liability in EFT transfers, the more I have to concede that this is a statutory framework that is woefully antiquated. Wire transfers used to be primarily for facilitating fund transfers by large companies and wealthy individuals (remember George Wainwright used a wire transfer to quickly send money to the Bailey's Saving and Loan on that fateful Christmas Eve).

But times have changed. Today, many banks and credit unions provide consumers easy online access to wire transfers. While this is a boon for convenience, it is also a boon for hackers who can transfer a member's life savings out of their account within seconds.

The premise of existing law is that wire transfers would be used to transfer a large amount of money between sophisticated actors, while the EFTA would be used to protect consumer transactions. While the lawyer in me agrees with and supports this crystal clear distinction, the policy wonk in me thinks it is inevitable that as the distinction between wire transfers and EFTA transactions becomes harder and harder to recognize, you will see Congress, Legislatures and if need be, the courts bend over backwards to place more liability on financial institutions, not because they have done something wrong, but because they will feel that the consumer needs their protection.

Henry Meier Henry Meier, Esq.

Henry Meier is the former General Counsel of the New York Credit Union Association, where he authored the popular New York State of Mind blog. He now provides legal advice to credit unions on a broad range of legal, regulatory and legislative issues. He can be reached at (518) 223-5126 or via email at henrymeieresq@outlook.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Digital Payments Lead the Way Globally: Key Insights from Worldpay Study

According to a recent Worldpay study, digital payments are rapidly becoming the preferred choice worldwide. The research highlights significant shifts in consumer behavior and payment preferences, driven by technological advancements and the growing acceptance of cashless transactions. Key findings from the study reveal that digital payments now account for a substantial portion of global transactions. Mobile wallets, contactless payments, and online banking are gaining traction, reflecting consumers' desire for convenience and speed. This trend is especially prominent in regions like Asia Pacific, where mobile payment adoption is leading the charge. The study also emphasizes the importance of security in fostering consumer trust in digital payments. As fraud concerns continue to rise, businesses must prioritize robust security measures to protect customer information and enhance the payment experience. Moreover, the transition to digital payments is not just about c...

NCOFCU - "Video Mini's" The Federal Reserve

The Federal Reserve, often referred to as the Fed, is the central banking system of the United States. Established in 1913 by the Federal Reserve Act, the Federal Reserve serves several crucial functions in the U.S. economy. Here are the main aspects of the Federal Reserve:  Visit NCOFCU's YouTube channel for more. "Video Mini's" The NCOFCU "Video Minis" are a series of concise 2-3 minute video presentations designed to deliver valuable insights and knowledge on key topics relevant to credit unions. Each video focuses on a specific subject, providing viewers with essential information in a brief and engaging format. These mini-presentations cover a range of subjects. Perfect for busy professionals seeking quick yet impactful content, the Video Minis make it easy to stay informed and enhance your credit union's operations and member services. Join us in exploring these informative and dynamic learning opportunities!

Fixed-Rate 30-Year Mortgage Decreases

MCLEAN, Va.--The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage averaged 6.65% this week, a slight decrease from last week's 6.6, Freddie mac reported. “The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage ticked down by two basis points this week,” said Sam Khater, Freddie Mac’s chief economist. “Recent mortgage rate stability continues to benefit potential buyers this spring, as reflected in the uptick in purchase applications.” Freddie Mac noted: The  30-year FRM  averaged 6.65% as of March 27, 2025, down from last week when it averaged 6.67%. A year ago at this time, the 30-year FRM averaged 6.79%. The  15-year FRM  averaged 5.89%, up from last week when it averaged 5.83%. A year ago at this time, the 15-year FRM averaged 6.11%.

President Trump is leading the way toward reduced check usage by phasing out paper checks for government payments.

WASHINGTON—A new  executive order  from President Donald Trump bans paper checks as a form of payment for the federal government. The order was signed noting that Treasury checks are often reported stolen, and face other issues. The order also notes that payments made  to  the federal government are also modernizing. “Check fraud is a perennial concern for the banking industry, growing in recent years – reports doubled from 2021 to 2022. Target stores announced last year that they would stop accepting paper checks,” the Independent Community Bankers of America pointed out. “It's a great sign that the government is leading the way toward reduced check usage by phasing out paper checks for government payments,” said ICBA payments expert Scott Anchin, noting that consumers and financial institutions should maintain the ability to determine appropriate payment mechanisms for specific cases.  ABA President and CEO Rob Nichols said his organization welcomes President ...

It Is Not Too Late!!!

Join NCOFCU and TCT Risk Solutions to find out if your financial health falls within the benchmark goals. About this FREE Event  Date and Time; Tue, July 14, 2020 2:00 PM – 3:00 PM EDT Add to Calendar Location; Online Event Register HERE Who should attend? CEO's, CFO's and Directors When you go to the Doctor, one of the first things to happen is the taking of your Vital Signs.  Health professionals know that these key Vital Signs provide an immediate picture of your body’s overall health. Monitoring your Vital Signs is an effective way to identify where your health in strong as well as where and when it requires attention. But it must be the right Vital Signs: for example, blood pressure, not hair length, or eye color. Just like people, Credit Unions have Vital Signs too. These vital signs indicate the overall financial health of the credit union. But, again, it must be the correct group of Vital Signs. Any indicator that is outside the healthy range me...