Skip to main content

It's Time to Rethink Member Segmentation

To provide more meaningful value to members, take a cue from how airline rewards programs are evolving.

By Scott Earwood | Select group of people Credit/AdobeStock

What do credit unions and airlines have in common? Think about the relationships airlines develop – they build status for people like Bronze, Silver, Gold or Platinum. These categories are set based on several factors (frequency of travel and finance factors including airline credit cards and in-app purchases). Credit unions take a similar approach to segmentation.

Whether running an airline or credit union, the problem is that this type of broad-stroke segmentation does not allow organizations to fully understand consumers. These categories fail to provide an accurate view of how consumers use services and interact with the organization. And, consumers are expecting more personalization.

Airlines are starting to ask for customers' unique preferences: Lucy, who prefers to book last-minute and fly first-class, now has the option to get more points and share a medallion status with her spouse for a reward, since the upgrades were meaningless to her; and Tom gets to airports early, so club access is his top priority, and he only wants upgrades if they are for an aisle seat. Both Lucy and Tom may be Platinum status, but they do not hold the same values for marketing or reward preferences. The level of segmentation is evolving.

There isn't a standard way for credit unions to segment members; some use the size of the account as a determining factor, while others look at the length of the membership or number of accounts. Perhaps the most common is ranking members based on their account balance. All of these methods fail to consider transactional, behavioral and product usage data. Such data allows credit unions to learn a members' interest and loyalty, equipping them to provide more personalized recommendations for products and services. Similar to how airline rewards are evolving, this helps credit unions provide more meaningful value to members.

Proper segmentation makes members feel known and understood; it builds stronger relationships. For example, a credit union may notice patterns in a member's behavior, such as more money going out to third-party providers and hopefully offer a better financial tool to manage their money. Or, perhaps another member jumps on any promotional offer on their credit card, but doesn't use it much, there may be a better rewards program for them. Taking this relational approach to banking keeps credit unions from becoming a commodity and builds relationships based on more than rates.

Better segmentation can also help credit unions with timely and appropriate communications. For example, if a member is considered a "saver," the credit union should consider personal outreach by checking in quarterly with targeted communications. Savers generally have a high lifetime value due to low attrition and high income, which is why consistent outreach and sensitivity to attrition is important. Conversely, "borrowers" or "super spenders" may benefit from an annual outreach to drive awareness and migrate deposits to digital. These insights can help credit unions determine the right contact models.

Implementing a new approach to segmentation and taking the time to learn about member preferences can elevate the banking experience to become more relational. Personalized segmentation can help credit unions develop relevant strategies that deepen and strengthen member relationships. In a time when every deposit matters, credit unions need to maximize the relationships they have – it all begins with knowing members better.

Scott Earwood Scott Earwood

Scott Earwood is the Director of Community Solutions at White Clay, a Louisville, Ky.-based provider of data and consulting services to banks and credit unions.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Both Sides of The Desk!

With over 50 years of experience in the credit union sector, I have had the privilege of observing and participating in its evolution from various vantage points. My journey has taken me from serving as a dedicated volunteer holding critical leadership roles, including serving on the supervisory committee, as director, and as board chairman, culminating in my tenure as CEO for 12 years and now founder and President/CEO of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions . This extensive background has enabled me to " Sit On Both Sides Of The Desk ," blending operational expertise with strategic oversight. In this blog post, I want to share how this dual perspective has enriched my understanding of credit union dynamics and fostered more effective governance. By leveraging the insights gained from years spent navigating both the intricacies of daily operations and the broader strategic objectives, I have witnessed firsthand the transformative power of collaboration, communi...

Fresh First Quarter 5300 Data Is Live. How Do You Compare?

  CALLAHAN RESOURCE Fresh First Quarter Data Is Live. How Do You Compare? The latest NCUA call report data is out, and while you’ve been focused on day-to-day priorities, market shifts might be affecting how you reach your goals. That’s why credit union leaders are already benchmarking performance to spot trends and inform their next moves. Ready to join them? Schedule a free performance analysis session with Callahan to gain a clear view of where you stand. Schedule Now

Fed Chair To Senate: Tariffs May Trigger Persistent Inflation, Slowing Rate Cut Plans

WASHINGTON— Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell told a U.S. Senate panel Wednesday that while the Trump administration’s tariffs may lead to a one-time spike in prices, the risk of more persistent inflation is significant enough for the central bank to proceed cautiously with any further interest rate cuts, Reuters reported. Although economic theory suggests tariffs are typically a temporary shock to prices, “that is not a law of nature,” Powell said, explaining that the Fed wants greater clarity on the scope of the tariffs and their impact on pricing and inflation expectations before making additional moves on borrowing costs, Reuters said. "If it comes in quickly and it is over and done then yes, very likely it is a one-time thing," that won't lead to more persistent inflation, Powell said. But "it is a risk we feel. As the people who are supposed to keep stable prices, we need to manage that risk. That's all we're doing," through holding rates steady ...

The Case for Sharing a CEO Between Credit Unions

  Embracing Collaboration: The Case for Sharing a CEO Between Credit Unions In recent years, credit unions have faced numerous challenges, from regulatory pressures to evolving member expectations. As many seasoned leaders retire, smaller credit unions often find themselves at a turning point. In this landscape, one innovative solution is gaining traction: sharing a CEO between two credit unions. This approach not only addresses financial constraints but also fosters collaboration and enhances service delivery. The Rationale Behind Sharing a CEO 1. Financial Sustainability One of the most pressing concerns for small credit unions is maintaining financial health amid rising operational costs. A shared CEO model alleviates the financial burden of hiring and compensating a full-time executive. By splitting salary and benefits, both credit unions can allocate resources more effectively, allowing for investment in member services, technology, and community initiatives. ...

Why Avoiding "I" in Marketing Presentations Matters

  Grant Sheehan, CCUE | CCUP | CEO NCOFCU  You know how things just stick with you? Well, many years ago, my marketing professor started off his class with the following, and it has never left me.  The Power of Perspective: Why Avoiding "I" in Marketing Presentations Matters In the world of marketing, effective communication is paramount. One valuable piece of advice that often comes from experienced instructors and industry veterans is the importance of avoiding the use of the word “I” in presentations and reports. At first glance, this may seem counterintuitive; after all, many individuals feel that personal anecdotes and experiences can enhance a message. However, upon deeper reflection, the reasoning behind this approach reveals itself as essential for achieving impactful communication. Building Objectivity When marketing professionals present their findings or insights, it’s important to establish credibility. Utilizing data, surveys, and feedback from cu...