Skip to main content

One Group of Competitors Has $3 Average OD Fee

By Ray Birch

LAKE FOREST, Ill.—A new study suggests credit unions should be less concerned about what big banks are doing with overdrafts and instead focus their attention on fintechs.

A new report from Moebs $ervices reveals fintechs continue to grab an even greater share of the checking market, and a big reason is a $3 average overdraft fee combined with targeted marketing.

“Fintechs are raking in the checking market share by going after those consumers who seldom overdraw but do so enough to add to profitability,” explained Michael Moebs, economist and chair of Moebs $ervices. “Fintechs are targeting, with one checking account, people with higher FICO scores. This is not what CUs, banks and thrifts are doing. Plus, most of the fintechs will pay interest on their checking account. It is classical financial services pricing— using fees, rates and balances.”

Feature Fintech OD

Moebs said fintechs are making their big move through “massive” national advertising.

“Especially in all sports—from auto racing to baseball to football to volleyball,” said Moebs. “Plus, the overall price is very reasonable and in most cases they pay interest, too. It took Chime only seven years to become profitable. Over half of all banks, credit unions, and savings banks do not have profitable checking.”

Market Share by Industry

The latest Moebs $ervices data show fintechs had 22.6% of the national checking market at year-end 2023, and six months later have 24% of the market.

“Credit unions have dropped to third in national checking market share, replaced by fintechs,” said Moebs. “They need to be much more competitive.”

Screenshot 2024-07-19 090205

Overall, the average overdraft list price from the fee schedules of financial institutions who have 76% of all 619 million checking accounts is $18.31 per overdraft transaction, the Moebs’ data show.

“This is down from yearend 2023 (-$1.22) or -6.2% annualized,” explained Moebs. “Some may say this is welcome relief from rising prices of all other services and products due to inflation—19.6% according to the Minneapolis Federal Reserve Core Inflation Calculator,” said Moebs. “The average overdraft price in 2020 when COVID 19 started was $30.49. So, this is a drop in the past four years of $12.18 or -39.9%, while core CPI drop rose 19.3%--remarkable changes by depositories of all types.”

What Analysis Also Shows

Moebs said the analysis shows OD price differences are widening among financial institution type.

“Overdraft prices now have great variance between FI types (see table),” said Moebs. “Banks are $5 higher than the average FI overdraft price of $18.”

Banks, such as Chase ($34 OD) and Wells Fargo ($35 OD) are not reducing price, noted Moebs.

“Banks cling to their dread of unsecured lending, which ODs are, and will not let go,” said Moebs, noting that is occurring despite all of the media attention given to large banks that have cut OD price or eliminated the charge. “Savings banks’ and credit unions’ list prices are less than the overall average. Yet, all of these FIs are losing market share to fintechs.”

Moebs Mike

Michael Moebs

In the past six months, banks, CUs and savings banks have lost 5% market share, while fintechs gained 5%.

The Need for a Strategy

Moebs said credit unions need to get in place a strategic overdraft price.

“Walmart’s $15 is driven by cost reduction of interchange normally paid out to Visa or Mastercard for Walmart purchases,” said Moebs. “BofA keeps their OD price lower or does not charge an OD if you do an auto loan or mortgage with them. Citibank wants profitable checking and will even not charge for overdrafts if the checking is profitable.”

The ’Essential Issue’

Moebs also emphasized that applying AI to debit scoring risk analysis leads to very low overdraft prices and high OD revenue.

“Defining risk is essential for OD pricing,” said Moebs. “It is time credit unions come to the right overdraft price. This is arrived at via a strategic combination of interchange, relationships, risk and profitability. Unprofitable checking and high overdraft pricing is second millennium thinking.”

Comments

Post a Comment

Please no profanity or political comments.

Popular posts from this blog

Why Auto Lending Is Starting To Stand Out As A Real Threat To CUs

  By Ray Birch MILWAUKEE—Auto lending is emerging as one of the biggest areas of risk for credit unions, even as the broader U.S. economy continues to perform better than many expected, according to Bill Handel, chief economist at Raddon, a Fiserv company. Delinquency trends in auto portfolios are now approaching levels last seen during the Great Financial Crisis, Handel said, driven by a combination of high vehicle prices, elevated interest rates and increasing financial pressure on lower-income consumers. “There’s probably still a lot of risk in the auto portfolios,” Handel said. “Our numbers in terms of delinquency behavior in the United States are now rivaling what they were during the Great Financial Crisis.” Economy Holding Up Better Than Expected Despite those pockets of risk, Handel said the broader economy remains surprisingly resilient. “If you look at the U.S. economy, it’s actually performing quite well—probably better than most people would have anticipated,” he said. ...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

When Cooperation Turns To Competition: A Turning Point For The Firefighter Credit Union Movement

  By Grant Sheehan For decades, firefighter credit unions have stood as a model of what cooperative finance is meant to be—institutions built not to compete ruthlessly, but to serve a shared mission: supporting the financial well-being of those who risk their lives in service to others. That’s what makes the recent actions of Firefighter First Credit Union so concerning. Firefighter First FCU was not just another participant; it was a founding member of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions (NCOFCU). It helped shape the very principles of collaboration, mutual respect, and non-encroachment that have long defined our community. Those principles weren’t accidental; they were intentional safeguards to ensure that firefighter-focused credit unions could grow together, not at each other’s expense. But something has changed. Firefighter First FCU’s decision to pursue a nationwide charter marks a clear shift in direction—from cooperation to direct competition. This isn’t simpl...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Small Credit Unions Don’t Lack Representation—They Lack Board Education

  By Grant Sheehan Let’s be clear— representation  for small credit unions is not something new that suddenly needs to be invented. For more than 150 years in Europe and 115 years in the U.S., many of us—along with numerous trade groups representing postal workers, schools, hospitals, the military, first responders, electricians, welders, auto workers, and many other sponsor employee groups—have been actively representing and supporting small credit unions. The mission has always been the same: protect these institutions and ensure they have a voice. The real challenge facing small credit unions has never been a lack of organizations claiming to represent them. The challenge has been engagement and education. Many small credit unions operate with extremely limited resources. Their boards are made up of volunteers who already have full-time careers. Even when scholarships, training opportunities, and conferences are offered, the realities of travel costs, staffing shortages, op...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

With Graham Signaling New Budget Bill, Credit Unions Brace For Tax Debate

By Ray Birch WASHINGTON— Senate Budget Committee Chairman Lindsey Graham’s comments Wednesday that Republicans will “expeditiously move toward creating a second budget reconciliation bill” are giving new shape to what had been a speculative discussion in Washington—and prompting renewed attention within the credit union industry to whether the movement’s federal tax exemption could again surface as lawmakers look for possible offsets. In a post on X, Graham said that after consulting with President Trump, his team and Senate Majority Leader John Thune, the Senate Budget Committee will move quickly on a second reconciliation package focused on “adequate funding to secure our homeland” and support for the military. The remarks are notable because they offer one of the clearest indications yet that a second fast-track budget measure—previously discussed but far from certain—may now be gaining traction. CUToday.info on Wednesday reached out to House Budget Committee Chairman Jodey Arringto...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

The United States at 250: How the Country Has Changed in the Past 50 Years

  In July, the United States will celebrate its 250th anniversary. The country’s last major milestone was 50 years ago, at its bicentennial on July 4, 1976. U.S. society has changed profoundly since then. Over the past five decades, the U.S. population has  aged significantly,  with the percentage of people 65 and older nearly doubling. The country has also become  more racially and ethnically diverse,  as growing shares of people identify as Asian or Hispanic. And following more than 70 million immigrant arrivals, the percentage of  foreign-born people  in the population has more than tripled.  Americans are also  less likely to be married  than ever before. Women – who now have far more options outside of the home than they did in 1976 – have contributed to a  boom in higher education  and helped  expand the workforce.  And even though many Americans are financially better off than they were 50 years ago,  econ...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Honoring Our Member Credit Unions Ranked Among the Top 100 in 2025

Celebrating Excellence: Honoring Our Member Credit Unions Ranked Among the Top 100 in 2025   Best-performing US credit unions of 2025 At NCOFCU, we take immense pride in the strength, resilience, and impact of our member credit unions. Today, we are thrilled to recognize and celebrate several of our members who have earned a place among the Top 100 Best Performing Credit Unions of 2025 —a testament to their unwavering commitment to service, financial stewardship, and community leadership. This achievement is not just about rankings—it reflects the daily dedication to members, the trust built within communities, and the innovation that continues to drive our movement forward. 🌟 Our Honored Members We proudly congratulate the following institutions for their outstanding performance: #7 – Long Beach Firemen's Credit Union A remarkable top-10 finish that highlights exceptional operational excellence and member value. Long Beach Firemen’s CU continues to set a high bar for perform...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

What Gen Z Is Really Looking For In A Credit Union

  Gen Z’s faith in traditional institutions gives credit unions a rich opportunity to serve as a key source of financial guidance. Sponsored Content By Adrenaline, Inc. Credit unions can strengthen loyalty with the influential Generation Z by connecting their brand’s purpose, financial guidance, and in-branch experience. Widely described as digital natives, Gen Z meets many of their everyday banking needs with mobile apps and digital tools across multiple providers. While younger consumers certainly expect seamless digital functionality from their primary financial provider, what they value even more is meaningful advice and trusting relationships. Because beneath Gen Z’s technological savvy is a measurable confidence gap —  one that impacts every aspect of their financial lives. According to  Adrenaline’s 2026 Gen Z research  conducted with Alexander Babbage, 36% of Gen Z say they find financial matters confusing, and one in three report feeling overwhelmed by money...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Credit Unions Look For Answers After NCUA Shake-Up

FAQ on Recent Firing of NCUA Board Members ,   click here. WASHINGTON—Do Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka have legal standing to contest their removal from the NCUA board by President Donald Trump? Has any past president taken similar action? Can NCUA continue functioning without a quorum on its board? Is this the first step toward consolidating federal banking regulators? In light of President Trump’s decision to remove Democratic NCUA board members Harper and Otsuka, many in the credit union community have expressed concerns and raised important questions. In response, America’s Credit Unions has prepared a detailed Q&A document addressing the implications of the White House’s actions announced on Wednesday. Below are key takeaways from the document ACU has shared with its members: President Trump may now nominate either one or two new board members to fill these vacant positions. At least one must be from a different political party, as statutorily required by the FCU Act. Or, l...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

One Fed Bank President Wants to See Rates at 3% or Higher by Year-End

James Bullard  ST. LOUIS–Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis President James Bullard said he would like to see the Fed’s benchmark rate increased to at least 3% by year-end 2022 to counter the highest inflation in four decades. Bullard also said he favors shrinking the Fed’s bloated balance sheet. “I would like the committee to get to 3-3.25% on the policy rate in the second half of this year,” Bullard told reporters after a speech at the University of Missouri, Bloomberg reported. “We have to move forthrightly in order to get the policy rate to the right level to deal with the inflation we have got in front of us.” As CUToday.info reported, the Fed raised its benchmark overnight rate by 25 basis points last month to a target range of 0.25% to 0.5%. Bullard, who favored a half-point increase, was the lone dissenter in the 8-1 policy vote. Bloomberg noted forecasts released with their policy decision showed officials expect to raise rates to 1.9% by the end of the year, ac...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»