Skip to main content

5 Key Areas Where Your Credit Union Needs Consistency

Consistency is the key to success for credit union growth when it's applied to five specific areas.

By Mark Arnold | August 12, 2024 at 09:00 AM

Personal workout plan with sneakers, smartphone and other fitness stuff Credit/AdobeStock

Any exercise trainer will tell you if you workout one day for 12 hours, you're going to be really sore. But if you work out 30 minutes a day for 30 days, you're going to be really fit. Why? Because consistency trumps intensity.

In a recent LinkedIn post, I noted that I'm often asked, what is the key to success for credit union growth? The one-word answer: Consistency. But not just random consistency. For credit unions it's consistency in five critical areas: Messaging, marketing, staff, sales and training.

Below is a breakdown of each of those areas along with a quick hack to ensure your credit union is bringing more consistency to them.

Messaging

Change is good. But not when it comes to your core messaging. You want items like your vision and tagline to remain consistent. The challenge with some credit unions is that they update their core messaging too frequently. Maybe they get tired of saying the same things. But repetition is often king.

Research suggests that consumers need to see information between five to seven times for it to transition to memory. Most marketing sources use the Rule of Seven: It takes exposing your message at least seven times before someone can recall it.

While your individual campaign concepts (think loan and deposit product promotions) certainly need creativity, it's your brand messaging that needs consistency. Consistently tell your stories and relate those stories back to your brand vision. Remember, one of the three "Cs" to a strong brand is consistency. The strongest brands today rarely deviate from their central message and themes.

Messaging Consistency Hack: Develop a brand plan and communicate to your niches. A brand plan details your core message and target audiences. It's hard to have a consistent message without a brand plan.

Marketing

Inconsistent marketing never works. Yet too many credit unions are guilty of this practice. We only market CDs and checking accounts when we need deposits. We need loans so we drop our auto rates and quickly put together a member email with a landing page talking about how great our auto loans are.

Marketing is not like a faucet that you can turn on and off when the mood strikes. It is much more like a soaker hose: You need a continual drip.

This is especially important in emails, social media and online efforts. The credit unions that have the most success in their digital marketing are the ones that consistently use SEO, PPC, geotargeting and online ad buys. The ones that struggle are the ones who fluctuate their spending.

Marketing Consistency Hack: Hire an outside partner to help fill in your consistency gaps. Consistency takes time and sometimes our marketing bandwidth is stretched thin. Having a partner that serves as your marketing arm leverages your resources.

Staff

One of the biggest areas credit unions struggle with when it comes to consistency is staff service. In some credit unions, a member won't get the answer they want from one particular branch, and they will drive clear across town to the same credit union but different branch hoping to get a different answer.

We see this when conducting mystery shops for our clients across the country. One branch will deliver an over-the-top engaging experience. Then another branch of the same credit union will completely bomb. Why? Because there is no consistency.

If your staff gives great service every now and then or only when they feel like it, then that is a lack of consistency. It's not enough to give a great member experience once. You need to do it every time.

Staff Consistency Hack: Create a journey map and brand service standards. Detail how you expect staff to treat members at every delivery channel (branch, phone, chat, etc.). In other words, operationalize your brand.

Sales

Leadership expert John Maxwell writes, "Small disciplines repeated with consistency every day lead to great achievements gained slowly over time." Nowhere do credit unions need more discipline than when it comes to sales.  Even though some credit unions may shy away from the "S" word, the truth is everyone is in sales.

But sales takes consistency – monthly, weekly and daily consistency. Practical sales techniques your employees should use include writing handwritten thank-you notes, recognizing members on their birthdays, asking where else members have other financial products (the average consumer has 10 financial products spread over four different financial institutions), conducting outbound phone calls and discussing product benefits rather than features.

Sales Consistency Hack: Create a follow-up system. Whether it's a complex CRM system or a simple Post-it note reminder, creating a way to consistently reach out to directly to members improves your sales. As networking expert Keith Ferrazzi says in his book "Never Eat Alone", "Follow-up is the key to success in any business."

Training

One trap many credit unions fall into is a "one and done" training approach. A one-time employee orientation. A one-day brand event. An annual employee rally. While all those are good, they often don't move the needle as much as you'd like. Why? Because training takes consistency and repetition.

Even the late great motivational speaker Zig Ziglar noted, "Repetition is the mother of learning, the father of action, which makes it the architect of accomplishment." If you want your employees to accomplish more, you have to train them more.

"We've found the credit unions that have the most employee engagement are the ones who invest in their experience training at least monthly," Laura Loy, experience director for On the Mark Strategies, said. "It's the consistent reminders that move the needle."

Training Consistency Hack: Conduct micro training, which are short but regular bursts of tips, tricks and learning. These could include 30-minute Zoom sessions, a short video or even quick, guided reads.

Dwayne (The Rock) Johnson doesn't work out 12 hours a day. But he does workout every day. He also notes, "Success isn't always about greatness. It's about consistency. Consistent hard work leads to success. Greatness will come."

And great growth success will come to your credit union when you bring more consistency to your messaging, marketing, staff, sales and training.

Mark Arnold Mark Arnold

Mark Arnold is founder and president of On the Mark Strategies, a Dallas, Texas-based consulting firm specializing in branding and strategic planning for credit unions.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

New York Stock Exchange building venue for 24/7 tokenized stock and ETF exchange

The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), via its owner   Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) , is building a new digital trading venue for 24/7 trading of tokenized stocks and ETFs, using blockchain and stablecoin-based funding for instant settlement, aiming to modernize markets by running parallel to the traditional exchange. This platform will support native digital securities and traditional shares as tokens, allowing for continuous liquidity and integrating digital assets into mainstream finance, with plans to launch later in 2026 after regulatory approval.   Key Features of the New NYSE Platform: 24/7 Trading:  Operates continuously, unlike the traditional exchange's weekday hours. Instant Settlement:  Transactions settle immediately, moving away from the current T+1 (trade date plus one day) model. Stablecoin-Based Funding :  Uses stablecoins (digital tokens pegged to fiat currency like the USD) for funding and collateral, streamlining processes outside banking hou...

Breaking: NCUA Moves to Remove a Major Barrier to Board Service

NCUA just proposed a rule that would allow federal credit unions to reimburse or directly pay reasonable dependent care costs for volunteer officials when those costs are incurred while attending board meetings or performing official duties. Childcare and eldercare costs are real barriers to serving on a board — especially for working professionals, single parents, and caregivers. At the same time, expectations for board engagement, training, and oversight continue to rise. A few important guardrails remain: ✔️ Applies only to federal credit unions ✔️ Covers dependent care only — not lost wages or compensation ✔️ Requires written board policy and reasonable controls ✔️ IRS tax treatment still applies (talk to your CPA) Bottom line: this won't fix board recruitment challenges by itself, but it removes a real friction point for people who want to serve and simply can't absorb the added costs. NCUA is also asking for comments — including whether training and conferences...

Sunday Reading - How pensions work

  The Pension Promise   How pensions work Colloquially speaking, pensions are retirement plans that result in employees receiving a fixed amount of money from their former employers during retirement, often for life (although the technical legal definition of pensions is significantly more nuanced ). Unlike “defined contribution plans” like 401(k) plans, “defined benefit plans” like pensions make it so the employer , rather than the employee, determines how much money is set aside for the plan and how it’s invested (often in stocks, bonds, and other assets). In retirement, monthly payouts include both the principal and investment earnings. Employers often use fact...

Small credit union closures and mergers.

NCOFCU Podcast on the loss of small creditunions. Grant Sheehan CCUE | CEO-NCOFCU examines the rapid decline of small credit unions, why each closure matters to communities, and the threat this trend poses to the cooperative identity and tax protections of the movement. The episode explores practical solutions: larger credit unions acting as stewards, collaboration through shared resources and technology, and the advocacy work of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions to amplify every credit union's voice. Listen for a call to action on preserving community-focused financial cooperatives and strengthening the future of the credit union movement. Be sure to visit NCOFCU's "First Responders Credit Unions Academy" for your continued credit union education and certification in meeting N C U A’s requirements.  ================================================= Remember, you're not alone with  NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional f...

Long-Stalled Credit Card Competition Act Moves Forward In Senate Clarity Act Markup

WASHINGTON—A long-stalled bipartisan push to boost competition in the credit card market moved closer to becoming law late Friday, as Sens. Roger Marshall (R-KS) and Dick Durbin (D-IL) advanced a new amendment attached to the Senate Agriculture Committee’s markup of the Digital Asset Market Structure and Investor Protection Act, commonly known as the Clarity Act. Dick Durbin The amendment, a core component of the long-debated Credit Card Competition Act, would prohibit major credit-card networks and large issuing banks from enforcing network exclusivity on credit cards. Supporters argue the measure would expand transaction-routing competition, weaken the dominance of the largest payment networks, and reduce swipe fees that merchants say inflate consumer prices. The renewed momentum reflects President Trump’s recent backing of efforts to rein in credit card costs, a shift that has altered the political trajectory of legislation that has struggled to advance in prior Congresses. With Tru...

NCUA Issues 2026 Supervisory Priorities Letter to Credit Unions

Alexandria, VA (January 14, 2026)  ― The National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) today announced its 2026 Supervisory Priorities, which continue the agency’s policy of “No Regulation by Enforcement,” while prioritizing safety and soundness. This policy underscores NCUA’s commitment to providing clarity and transparency in its oversight. The letter outlines NCUA’s priorities for the year and provides information to help credit unions prepare for examinations. This year, the agency will continue to focus on risk-based supervision, tailoring the examination scope to the credit union’s unique risk profile. Key Highlights of the 2026 Supervisory Priorities: Risk-Focused Examinations:  Examiners will concentrate on areas posing the greatest risk to credit union members, the credit union system, and the Share Insurance Fund. Balance Sheet Management and Lending:  With loan performance at its weakest point in over a decade, examiners will review credit risk management practic...

What Will 2026 Hold for CUs?

NEW YORK—As credit unions look to the new year, forecasters heading into 2026 see the U.S. economy cooling but not collapsing, with slower job growth, easing inflation and modest interest-rate cuts forming the backbone of a “soft-landing” outlook that still hinges on big unknowns: trade policy, geopolitics, fiscal decisions in Washington and whether households keep spending after several years of higher prices. Credit union leaders know they have a stake in all of that and more. In addition to the economic forecasts below, the CU Daily also other 2026-related previews, including: 2026 Forecast: The Auto Sales, Lending Trends to be Watching 2026 Forecast: What Companies are Saying About Hiring in New Yea r 2026 Forecast: FASB Puts Two Digital Asset Topics on its Agenda 2026 Forecast: How One Large Bank is Deploying Generative AI 2026 Forecast: Automobile Prices to Remain High as Loan Terms Get Longer 2026 Forecast: Is This a Model for How CUs Might Approach Workforce & AI? What the ...

NCUA’s Hood Sees Lessons From Pandemic; ID’s Priorities Moving Forward

  ORLANDO, Fla.–NCUA Board Member Rodney Hood told credit unions here that if there is a lesson from the last year it was summed up in a meeting breakout session title: “Transitioning from Risk to Resilience.” “That title stood out to me, because in five simple words it sums up the journey we’ve taken since March 2020, doesn’t it?” Hood said in comments to the League of Southeastern Credit Unions’ annual meeting here. After referencing some of the events since the pandemic shut down the economy, Hood told attendees, “Our nation has faced many challenges in our lifetimes, but few compare to what was unfolding before our eyes this time last year.” Hood said the “resilience” of credit unions can be seen in the latest data, with federally insured credit unions reporting net income growth of $11.3 billion, an increase of 134.9% over the year ending in the first quarter of 2021 (a figure boosted by CUs reducing their allowances for loan losses). The Reality The good news and the desire...

How to Avoid Becoming a Target of Regulators

By Ray Birch LAKE FOREST, Ill.—A “new era” in checking—and overdrafts—is upon financial institutions, and those that adopt the new ways of the market will prosper, while those that don’t will lose money and will likely become a target of regulators, one economist is stating. “What is the new era of checking? Checking has always been unprofitable,” said Michael Moebs, economist and chair of Moebs $ervices. “The Great Recession era from 2008 to 2014 finally made this obvious to users, regulators, and Congress. COVID, from 2019 to 2022, made it a an even clearer issue today.” Profitable checking is the key to driving deposit funding for loans and investments, reminded Moebs. “There are about 9,000 financial institutions that offer checking,” state...