Skip to main content

A new rule could make it easier to switch your bank. (Guess who hates it.)

Federal regulators want to make it less of a pain to change your bank — but first, it looks like they’ll have to win a battle in court.

On Tuesday, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) unveiled the final version of its highly anticipated open banking rule, which aims to create more competition between financial services companies by making it simpler for customers to transfer their personal data between them.

The measure is in part designed to relieve some of the common headaches familiar to anyone who has ever tried to move their checking account or upgrade to a better credit card — a process that can require manually resetting a number of automatic bill payments and may mean losing years' worth of transactions history.

Those kinds of inconveniences are known to keep many consumers from shopping around for better deals. One survey found that the average American has had the same checking account for more than 17 years; about 10% of consumers say they haven’t switched mostly because of the hassle involved.

During a speech in Philadelphia, CFPB Director Rohit Chopra said the agency’s new regulation, officially known as rule 1033, would help remove some of those “roadblocks.” Under the measure, banks, credit card issuers, and payment apps will be required to provide customers electronic access to their account data, including by giving third parties of their choice permission to collect it — making it seamless for fintech firms and other institutions to plug in and transfer over key information.

“That means you can more easily walk away from mediocre products or services,” Chopra said. He compared the changes to rules that allowed cell phone customers to take their numbers with them when they changed service providers, which made jumping to a new plan far easier.

The rule has drawn fierce criticism from banks, however, who argue that it will be unfairly expensive for them to implement and expose customers to serious fraud risks. On Wednesday, industry groups filed a federal lawsuit in Kentucky aiming to halt the regulation, accusing the CFPB of “overstepping its statutory mandate.”


What’s really changing

For many consumers, the new open banking rule might not seem to change much at first glance. According to the CFPB, at least 100 million Americans already let third parties access their various financial accounts, using apps like Plaid to connect their banks and brokerages to personal budgeting software and services like TurboTax. That’s led some to downplay the significance of the agency’s new regulation.

“In a lot of senses, 1033 is just a formalization of the digital finance economy as it already exists,” Plaid CEO Zach Perret, told a crowd at a fintech conference Wednesday.

But regulators and outside supporters argue that the open banking rule will make important behind-the- scenes changes benefiting consumers. Today, they note, banks can pick and choose which companies they let touch their customers’ data, and on what terms. Tech firms that they refuse to work with often resort to workarounds like “screen scraping,” which are widely considered security risks.

The new rule will force banks to give access to any third party that customers want using a formal portal, as long as they meet certain standard requirements. It also creates privacy rules about how data can be handled once it’s ported over so that the information can only be used as the customers intend.

“At its core, the rule that the CFPB put out says that it’s not up to the bank, it’s up to you,” said Steve Boms, executive director of the Financial Data and Technology Association of North America. “Your bank can’t stand in front of you and say, ‘No we don’t think so.’”

How consumers could benefit

Beyond making it more convenient to hop between banks, advocates say the new data rules open up new, consumer-friendly ways to make everyday purchases and apply for credit that could shake up big swaths of consumer finance.

One type of service that could potentially see growth: Pay-by-bank apps, which let customers buy things or cover bills directly from their checking account, rather than via a debit card or paper check. Retailers are already cheering that possibility, since those services could save merchants the so-called swipe fees that banks and other card issuers collect on each transaction. Some could eventually offer discounts to customers who use a pay-by-bank option instead of whipping out a Visa or Mastercard.

“Open banking could cut out these middlemen and create competition that would benefit small businesses and consumers alike,” National Retail Federation general counsel Stephanie Martz said in a statement this week.

Experts also say the data rules make it easier for some Americans to get access to loans via cash-flow underwriting, where lenders assess creditworthiness by looking at an applicant’s history of paying their rent and bills on time. That could be especially helpful to immigrants and young people who tend to have thin credit files.

Why banks are ticked

Banks have raised a number of complaints about the new data rules, starting with the expense.

The regulations will ban financial institutions from charging any fees to fintech firms for accessing customer data, while requiring they pay out for new compliance costs. They also argue that the new rules don’t do enough to shield them from legal and financial liability if a third party isn’t careful with the information they gather, or misuses it. That’s an especially acute problem, the industry says, since allowing more third parties to pick through data increases the odds of a bad actor slipping through.

“It’s just another vector and another chance for fraud to really be magnified,” said Brian Fritzsche, associate general counsel at the Consumer Bankers Association.

In its lawsuit filed Wednesday, the Bank Policy Institute argues that regulators went well beyond the authority outlined in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, which called for data regulations. “This is a case about a federal agency overstepping its statutory mandate and injecting itself into a developing, well-functioning ecosystem that is thriving under private initiatives,” the complaint states.

It’s asking the courts to overturn the rules entirely — or, failing that, to let banks charge fees to all those fintech firms that will be clamoring for access to the data.

Jordan Weissmann is a senior reporter at Yahoo Finance.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sunday Reading - Social Security 101

  Social Studies   Social Security 101 The US Social Security   system is best known for providing income to the nation’s elderly population based on the amount of money they earned during their working years.   The Social Security Act of 1935 established the program  amid the worsening poverty crisis that older Americans faced during the Great Depression. By 1934, more than half of those aged 65 and older lacked sufficient income to cover their basic living expenses.    Today, most US workers are familiar with seeing a percentage of their pretax income deducted from their paychecks and contributed to the nation’s Social Security trust funds. Starting a...

Dolphin Debit Drives Efficiency

  Contact Us   4k Surcharge-Free ATMs for Free   Dolphin Debit Access | 1340 Rayford Rd | Spring, TX 77386 . Joe Woods, CUDE  | SVP, Marketing & Partnerships Dolphin Debit Access, LLC | A Euronet Company 1340 Rayford Park Rd., Spring, TX 77386 (M) 614-378-0367   www.dolphindebit.com ================================================= Remember, you're not alone with  NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional features: First Responder Credit Union Academy Financial Literacy Podcasts YouTube Mini's Blog Job Board

“The CU Teller of the Future”:

  “The CU Teller of the Future” : Credit union tellers will continue to play an important role, but their work will shift from routine transactions to relationship-driven financial guidance. Technology will handle more basic tasks, freeing tellers to focus on personalized service, financial coaching, and member trust. What Future Tellers Will Focus On The teller of the future will deliver member-centric, personalized experiences by anticipating needs, offering proactive guidance, and explaining financial products in simple, supportive ways. They’ll need to be comfortable working across multiple channels —in person, mobile, chat, and video—while keeping service seamless. A security-first mindset will be essential, including fraud awareness and helping members practice safe digital habits. Tellers will also play a growing role in financial wellness , assisting with budgeting, saving, debt management, and long-term planning. Strong knowledge of compliance and documentation will...

'Tis the season for fraud! Teller questions if member fraud is suspected.

  When a credit union employee suspects a member may be subject to fraud, they should initiate a careful conversation focusing on the nature of the transaction and external influences. The goal is to help the member identify red flags without the employee asking for sensitive personal information that the credit union should already have on file.  Initial Verification Questions    .pdf Before discussing the specifics of the suspicious activity, the employee should confirm the member's identity in accordance with established internal protocols.  Questions About the Transaction/Activity If the member confirms they are conducting a suspicious transaction (e.g., a large wire transfer or purchase of gift cards ), the employee should ask questions to help the member pause and think critically:  "What is the purpose of this transaction?" "Do you personally know the person or business you are sending money to?" "Have you ever met the...

Advice On Winning Over Gen Z In ’25

NEW YORK—As 2025 approaches the close of Q1, how can credit unions win over Gen Z? By tailoring credit rewards for a digital-first generation, a new report recommends. Gen Z is reshaping the workforce and redefining financial behaviors. As of 2024, this generation is poised to surpass Baby Boomers in workforce size and will make up 30% of the workforce by 2030. This rapid growth presents a major opportunity for financial institutions to tap into a younger, digitally native audience with distinct spending habits and financial needs, emphasized a GlobalData report authored by Zachary Johnson, specialist, campaign execution & strategy, financial services at VDX.tv. “Unlike previous generations, Gen Z’s economic journey has been shaped by inflation and delayed career starts due to the pandemic and skyrocketing living costs. These factors have made them highly dependent on credit, with Gen Zers being 23% more likely to own a credit card than Millennials at the same age, and carrying...

‘No One Wants a New Car Now.’ WSJ Columnist Offers His Take on Why

NEW YORK–That new car smell isn’t quite the intoxicating perfume it has been for a long time, according to one automotive analyst. Under the headline, “No One Wants a New Car Now. Here’s Why,” the Wall Street Journal’s well-regarded automotive columnist, Dan Neal, observed that “America’s fleet of cars and trucks is also getting long in the tooth.” Neal’s reference was to a study by S&P Global Mobility that found the average age of vehicles in the U.S. is now 12.6 years, up more than 14 months since 2014, with the average age of passenger cars hitting14 years. All-Time High Burden “In the past, the average-age statistic was taken as a sign of transportation’s burden on household budgets,” Neal wrote. “Those burdens remain near all-time hig...

IRS Issues Ruling on Federal Credit Unions and COVID Credit

WASHINGTON–The Internal Revenue Service has issued a ruling that credit unions can receive a 2021 COVID Credit, but not 2020. In other words, federally chartered CUs can’t claim the employee retention credit for periods in 2020 but can do so for periods in 2021, because later amendments to the terms of the credit made them eligible, according to the IRS. Specifically, FCUs can’t claim the credit for wages paid after March 12, 2020, and before Jan. 1, 2021. The ruling was issued by the IRS Office of Chief Counsel in a newly released legal  memorandum . According to the IRS, FCUs are able to claim the credit for wages paid after Dec. 31, 2020, and before Oct. 1, 2021, the IRS said. The Employee Retention Credit (ERC) – sometimes called the Empl...

Three-Quarters of Consumers Familiar With CUs, But Just 1 in 4 Says a CU is PFI, & Other New Findings

WASHINGTON– More than three-quarters of U.S. consumers said they are familiar with credit unions and hold a positive impression, yet just one-in-four banks primarily with a credit union, a new survey has found. The 2026 Credit Union Consumer Perception Report from  CUCollaborate  surveyed 1,000 consumers across the U.S. in December 2025 to gauge their opinions on credit unions. It further found early 70% describe credit unions as trustworthy, and a majority recognize their advantages in fees and rates compared to traditional banks.  But positive sentiment is in decline with younger bankers, according to CUCollaborate. Gen Z consumers represented a sharp shift in credit union perception from older generations, the company said, noting that among those respondents, 36% indicated they had only heard the term “credit union” without having a deeper understanding or had never heard of the term at all.  Some “44% said they were somewhat familiar with credit unions, and a me...

Small credit union closures and mergers.

NCOFCU Podcast on the loss of small creditunions. Grant Sheehan CCUE | CEO-NCOFCU examines the rapid decline of small credit unions, why each closure matters to communities, and the threat this trend poses to the cooperative identity and tax protections of the movement. The episode explores practical solutions: larger credit unions acting as stewards, collaboration through shared resources and technology, and the advocacy work of the National Council of Firefighter Credit Unions to amplify every credit union's voice. Listen for a call to action on preserving community-focused financial cooperatives and strengthening the future of the credit union movement. Be sure to visit NCOFCU's "First Responders Credit Unions Academy" for your continued credit union education and certification in meeting N C U A’s requirements.  ================================================= Remember, you're not alone with  NCOFCU.org Join/Upgrade Check out some of NCOFCU's additional f...