Skip to main content

Steve Rick - Small CUs Beating Big CUs In Key Performance Area

MADISON, Wis.—The current rate environment, for a change, may actually be favoring small CUs, data from TruStage’s latest Trends Report show.

The September Trends Report, which is based on CU performance through July, reveals the credit union return-on-asset ratio fell to 0.66% in the first six months of 2024, on an annualized basis, down from 0.78% in the first six months of 2023.

The 12-basis point decrease in earnings during the last year was driven by a 15-basis point increase in provisions for loan losses as a percent of average assets, and a 7-basis point increase in operating expense ratios, the report states.

T equity and other

Higher Earnings

Partially offsetting the expense increase was a 3-basis point increase in net interest margins and a 6-basis point increase in fee and other income ratios. Credit unions with assets greater than $50 million reported a drop in earnings while smaller credit unions reported higher earnings due to the difference in the increase in their cost of funds ratios.

RickSteve New

Steve Rick

“For example, billion-dollar credit unions saw their cost of funds ratios rise from 1.33% during the first half of 2023, to 2.03% in the first half of 2024, a 70-basis point increase. Meanwhile, credit unions with assets less than $20 million saw their cost of funds increase from 0.45% in 2023 to 0.81% in 2024, a 36-basis point increase,” wrote TruStage Chief Economist Steven Rick. “This cost of funds disparity is due to bigger credit unions relying more on higher-cost money market and certificates of deposit accounts for funding. So, for the first time in many years, these smaller credit unions reported a return-on-asset ratio similar to the billion-dollar credit unions.”

Membership Growth

Aside from rates, small shops continued to struggle, particularly with membership growth. Credit union memberships grew 0.1% in July 2024, below the 0.4% reported in July 2023, due to a significant reduction in auto loan originations and slower job growth. On an annual growth rate basis, memberships are up only 1.2% in the year ending in July 2024, below the 4.3% pace set in the year ending in July 2023. ‘

“This 1.2% pace is the slowest since the tail end of the Great Recession in November 2011. The membership growth slowdown was partially driven by the 2.4 million jobs gained during the last year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which is below the 3.2 million jobs gained in the year ending in July 2023,” Rick wrote.

The slowdown in membership growth in 2024, compared to 2023, was seen across the board. Most credit unions with less than $100 million in assets reported negative membership growth while credit unions with assets greater than $1 billion reported relatively strong membership growth of 3.8% due to organic growth and mergers.

“Credit unions should expect membership growth around 1.5% in 2024, and a slightly better 1.8% membership growth is forecasted for 2025 as loan growth picks up,” Rick said.

T CUs and members

Comments

Post a Comment

Please no profanity or political comments.

Popular posts from this blog

Where are your children banking?

  Grant Sheehan CCUE | CCUP | CEO, NCOFCU The B reach  Between Purpose and Experience Just recently, I came across a story that has stayed with me. It wasn’t dramatic in the traditional sense. There was no scandal, no crisis, no headline-grabbing failure. In fact, it was something much quieter than that. It was simply the story of an eighteen-year-old leaving his credit union. On the surface, that might not sound remarkable. Young people move their money frequently. They open new accounts, experiment with apps, follow trends, and often make financial decisions influenced by the digital tools at their disposal. But this story was different. This young man had been a credit union member since he was a few weeks old, as many credit unions do. His mother has spent her career working inside the credit union movement as an executive. For eighteen years, his financial life was connected to a credit union. If anyone might be expected to remain a lifelong member, it wou...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Sunday Reading - March Madness, explained

  The Big Dance   March Madness, explained "March Madness" is the well-known name for the NCAA's annual Division I men's and women's basketball tournaments, which determine national champions through a 68-team , single-elimination format. Automatic bids go to 31 conference winners, while 37 at-large selections fill the field. The high-stakes structure—where smaller "Cinderella" schools can upset powerhouses—drives huge viewership and revenue; TV and marketing rights account for roughly two-thirds of the NCAA's $1.4B income in fiscal 2024. The National Inv...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Economic and Industry Issues

Weekly News Summary -  July 30, 2020 Press Release For Immediate Release Weekly News Summary Hello NCOFCU Members, Here are some things that were in the news last week. Please share these articles with your Supervisory Committee and Board of Directors. If you missed previous editions of the weekly news, summaries of those can be viewed at our  archive .  Have a great week! Mike Richards, CPA         The Callahan Credit Union A...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Three Tips for Better Google Searching - NYTimes.com

Here are the three tips — basic, intermediate and advanced — from Dan Russell at Google. He studies how people use the search engine and teaches classes on how to do it better , including a free online course this month, for which registration started Tuesday. He promises these tips will make you happy, and he cares a lot about that — his official title at Google is über tech lead for search quality and user happiness.----- Three Tips for Better Google Searching - NYTimes.com
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Firefighters Community CU Casual for a Cause

The $185 million Firefighters Community Credit Union in Cleveland is one of many across the country participating in Miracle Jeans Day on Wednesday. More than 40 of the 50 or so employees at the 25,000-member credit union have paid $5 for the right to go casual that day at work, and the staff so far as raised $310 for the effort to help local Children’s Miracle Network Hospitals-------- Casual for a Cause
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

5 Red Flags: When Boards Lean Too Heavily on Management

  The Quiet Governance Risk Credit Unions Should Talk About By Grant Sheehan, CCUE | CCUP | CEO, NCOFCU Having spent many years both serving on a credit union board and leading as a CEO , I’ve had the opportunity to see governance from both sides of the table. That perspective has given me a deep appreciation for the delicate balance that must exist between management, leadership, and board oversight. When that balance works well, credit unions thrive. But when it slowly shifts — often unintentionally — it can create governance weaknesses that regulators and examiners increasingly watch for. In conversations with governance professionals and through years of industry experience, one theme keeps emerging: most governance problems don’t begin with bad intentions or misconduct. They begin with boards that gradually become too dependent on management. This is rarely obvious at first, but in fact, it often occurs within high-performing organizations. But slight patterns ca...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Credit Unions Offering Unique Financial Strategies for Women

Women of all ages and walks of life are in a unique place financially in today’s day and age, fulfilling more roles than in years past including that of professional, mother, homemaker, business woman, student, etc. More is expected of modern women and yet they still tend to earn less than their male counterparts. According to the US Census Bureau, the median income of a woman with a bachelor’s degree is about 67 percent as much as that of a man with a bachelor’s degree-------- Credit Unions Offering Unique Financial Strategies for Women
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Americans are using alternative financing arrangements, such as rent-to-own

CUToday PHILADELPHIA–Many Americans are using alternative financing arrangements, such as rent-to-own, that a new report from Pew Charitable Trusts indicates are generally riskier, more costly, and subject to far weaker consumer protections and regulatory oversight than traditional mortgages. Pew Trusts sad the “evidence suggests that a shortage of small mortgages, those for less than $150,000, may be driving some home borrowers (i.e., people who purchase a home with financing) who could qualify for a mortgage into these alternative arrangements. And other factors related to a home’s habitability and the ownership of the land beneath a manufactured home—the modern version of a mobile home—can make certain homes ineligible for mortgage financing altogether.” According to Pew, the evidence of potential consumer harm, little is known about the prevalence of alternative financing in the U.S., primarily because no systematic national data collection exists. Pew said approximate...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Stay-at-home parents getting new credit card rule - Sep. 24, 2012

Help is on the way for stay-at-home parents being denied credit cards because they don't have income of their own. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau will propose a rule within the next few months that will make it easier for applicants without personal income to qualify for credit cards, the agency's director Richard Cordray said at a congressional hearing last week..... Read More At .. Stay-at-home parents getting new credit card rule - Sep. 24, 2012
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»

Do you know where your credit union stands on executive compensation and benefits?

Do you know where your credit union stands on executive compensation and benefits? : Every credit union is unique, and every CEO places a different emphasis on how they want their executive compensation and benefits package tailored, which makes an assessment of ‘market rates’ for executive benefits and compensation challenging. If you’re a board member you want to be both fair to your executives, provide a combination of compensation and benefits with the right mix of incentives to ensure alignment with your strategic goals, and also fulfill your fiduciary obligation to fellow credit union members. As an executive, you want to make sure that your compensation and benefits are competitive and fit your personal needs, and are also flexible enough to adapt as those needs change throughout your career. One great way to find out where your credit union stands relative to the market is with the NAFCU-Burns-Fazzi, Brock (BFB) Executive Compensation and Benefits Survey (free to survey pa...
Post a Comment
Read Complete Article HERE>»