Steve Rick - Small CUs Beating Big CUs In Key Performance Area

MADISON, Wis.—The current rate environment, for a change, may actually be favoring small CUs, data from TruStage’s latest Trends Report show.

The September Trends Report, which is based on CU performance through July, reveals the credit union return-on-asset ratio fell to 0.66% in the first six months of 2024, on an annualized basis, down from 0.78% in the first six months of 2023.

The 12-basis point decrease in earnings during the last year was driven by a 15-basis point increase in provisions for loan losses as a percent of average assets, and a 7-basis point increase in operating expense ratios, the report states.

Higher Earnings

Partially offsetting the expense increase was a 3-basis point increase in net interest margins and a 6-basis point increase in fee and other income ratios. Credit unions with assets greater than $50 million reported a drop in earnings while smaller credit unions reported higher earnings due to the difference in the increase in their cost of funds ratios.

Steve Rick

“For example, billion-dollar credit unions saw their cost of funds ratios rise from 1.33% during the first half of 2023, to 2.03% in the first half of 2024, a 70-basis point increase. Meanwhile, credit unions with assets less than $20 million saw their cost of funds increase from 0.45% in 2023 to 0.81% in 2024, a 36-basis point increase,” wrote TruStage Chief Economist Steven Rick. “This cost of funds disparity is due to bigger credit unions relying more on higher-cost money market and certificates of deposit accounts for funding. So, for the first time in many years, these smaller credit unions reported a return-on-asset ratio similar to the billion-dollar credit unions.”

Membership Growth

Aside from rates, small shops continued to struggle, particularly with membership growth. Credit union memberships grew 0.1% in July 2024, below the 0.4% reported in July 2023, due to a significant reduction in auto loan originations and slower job growth. On an annual growth rate basis, memberships are up only 1.2% in the year ending in July 2024, below the 4.3% pace set in the year ending in July 2023. ‘

“This 1.2% pace is the slowest since the tail end of the Great Recession in November 2011. The membership growth slowdown was partially driven by the 2.4 million jobs gained during the last year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which is below the 3.2 million jobs gained in the year ending in July 2023,” Rick wrote.

The slowdown in membership growth in 2024, compared to 2023, was seen across the board. Most credit unions with less than $100 million in assets reported negative membership growth while credit unions with assets greater than $1 billion reported relatively strong membership growth of 3.8% due to organic growth and mergers.

“Credit unions should expect membership growth around 1.5% in 2024, and a slightly better 1.8% membership growth is forecasted for 2025 as loan growth picks up,” Rick said.

Comments

Sunday Reading - Changing the Map

Changing the Map Redistricting, explained Congressional redistricting is the process by which states redraw electoral district boundaries that determine representation in the US House of Representatives. The Constitution, federal law, and court rulings require districts to have roughly equal populations, avoid discrimination against racial or language minorities, and, in most states, be geographically contiguous. For most of American history, redistricting has followed a predictable cycle, occurring every 10 years after the census. Gerrymandering is the deliberate manipulation of district boundaries to advantage one political party. Common tactics by both major American political parties include packing opposition voters i...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Reuters: Trump Regulators Launch Biggest Bank Oversight Overhaul Since 2008

Is NCUA next? WASHINGTON—Federal banking regulators under President Trump are undertaking what Reuters described as the most significant overhaul of bank supervision since the 2008 financial crisis, shifting examiner focus away from process and compliance issues and toward what agencies consider “material” financial risks. According to Reuters, the Federal Reserve, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. have directed examiners to concentrate on risks that pose direct threats to a bank’s safety and soundness, rather than on paperwork deficiencies, governance concerns or procedural issues that do not immediately affect financial stability. Reuters reported that regulators have also moved away from evaluating banks based on “reputational risk,” a supervisory concept long criticized by banks as overly subjective. The change follows complaints from President Trump and others that financial institutions have used reputational-risk considerations...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Trump Accounts Program For Children Moves Forward With New Mobile App Launch

WASHINGTON—The Treasury Department on Thursday announced the launch of the new Trump Accounts mobile app, marking the next phase of the Administration’s rollout of its new federally backed investment savings program for children ahead of the program’s official July 4 launch date. Donald Trump The app, now available through major mobile app stores, will serve as the primary platform for families to manage and activate Trump Accounts. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the app is intended to give parents and guardians a “simple, secure way” to participate in the program, which was created under the 2025 Republican tax-and-spending package. Families that already submitted IRS Form 4547 to enroll children in the program will begin receiving phased activation emails between now and July 4, according to Treasury. Under the program, eligible children born between Jan. 1, 2025, and Dec. 31, 2028, can receive a one-time $1,000 federal seed contribution into a tax-deferred investment ac...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

IRS Reporting Proposal Scaled Back, but Still 'Flawed'

On Tuesday, Senate Democrats distributed an update to the controversial IRS reporting requirements that the credit union industry has been very vocally opposed to since it was unveiled in late June. According to the updated proposal rolled out Tuesday, it would require financial institutions to report inflows and outflows of personal and business accounts, as well as transfers between accounts of the same owner, if it is more than $10,000 per year. The proposal floating around for the past four months had the threshold at $600 per year. The requirements do not apply to payroll deposits for wages or to those receiving Social Security benefits. In response to the updated IRS reporting proposal, NAFCU President/CEO Dan Berger said, “It has become abundantly clear that Americans oppose the IRS obtaining additional information on their financial accounts. The updated plan is nothing more than window dressing in an attempt to shore up support for a flawed proposal. Instead of creating financ...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Proposed FOM changes would streamline ability to reach underserved

February 16, 2023 The NCUA Board proposed chartering and field-of-membership changes and issued its final cyber incident reporting rule at its Thursday meeting. The board also heard a quarterly update on the share insurance fund, which noted an increase in the fund's equity ratio to 1.30%." The proposal would amend the chartering and FOM rules through nine changes to enhance consumer access to financial services, especially in low- and moderate-income communities while reducing duplicative or unnecessary paperwork and administrative requirements. “Getting credit union services to more communities across the country is important to CUNA, state leagues and the credit unions we serve, and making that easier to achieve has a big impact on access,” said CUNA Deputy Chief Advocacy Officer Jason Stverak. “While we need to review the proposal in detail, we thank the NCUA board for working to streamline the ability of credit un...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Visa, Mastercard Revisions Will Cost Merchants more Than $475 Million Annually, Economist Says

NEW YORK—The two biggest U.S. card networks are preparing revisions to their interchange schedules that at least one research firm says will cost U.S. merchants an estimated $475 million in additional transaction fees. Though Visa Inc. and Mastercard Inc. have historically revised their rate schedules each April and October, “this April is particularly significant,” Callum Godwin, the Atlanta-based chief economist for CMSPI, a United Kingdom-based research firm, told Digital Transactions. The firm’s estimates indicate the changes in Visa’s rates will add up to a net $145 million in additional cost to acquirers. For Mastercard, the impact will net out to $330 million. The networks do not collect interchange. Merchant processors pay in...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

IRS Reporting Requirement Has Turned Into Uphill Battle for CUs

It’s in. It’s out. It’s in again. On Thursday, NAFCU, CUNA and more than 100 associations sent a letter to all members of the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate asking them to reject a proposed IRS reporting requirement that credit union trades have been pushing back against since July . The proposed IRS reporting requirement would require financial institutions, including credit unions, to report the inflows and outflows of personal and business accounts, as well as transfers between accounts of the same owner, if it is more than $600 per year. The proposal found new life inside the House version of the budget reconciliation bill after it was rejected in the version approved by the House Ways and Means Committee last month. On Tuesday, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said the IRS reporting requirement would be included in the House version of the bill. CUNA, NAFCU and other organizations voiced their objections to the proposal in a joint letter. While the l...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Credit Where Credit's Due

Credit Where Credit's Due Credit reports 101 Used to calculate credit scores and determine creditworthiness, credit reports are comprehensive documents that detail the credit history of a person or business, including current and former lines of credit, bankruptcy records, and more. Credit assessments actually started in the 1700s as a way to evaluate businesses’ financial standing rather than consumers’. The early 1800s brought efforts to standardize the credit reporting system as more businesses were started that needed loans, and the labor movement’s success in the second half of the 1800s led to an increased need for standardized c...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Cheer Up and Change: "Wait and see is not a plan."

I posted this a year ago and thought I would bring it back to see if any of his predictions came true. Take a look and tell us what you think. Grant Sheehan CEO Cheer Up and Change: The Demographic Mandate At a conference I recently attended Monday morning started off with a great session by demographer and futurist Ken Gronbach, who laid out his predictions on where we’re going and what we can expect as demographics change. I was pleasantly surprised that the future isn’t sounding as bleak as the news might have you believe. Gronbach offered lots of predictions for where our society and our world is headed. His predictions were given with a purpose: To help associations build their vision and plan for the future. As Gronbach stressed, "Wait and see is not a plan." I’ve decided to arrange this recap into a list of my takeaways rather than a narrative recap. I hope you get as much out of this information as I did! Things to Expect: Big Changes in Retail : Gronbach ...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

Supplemental Capital to be Considered by NCUA

Supplemental Capital At the NCUA’s October board meeting, senior staff of the NCUA submitted a briefing report (the “Report”) to the NCUA Board (the “Board”) on the issues concerning the use of supplemental capital by federally insured credit unions (“FICUs”). The use of supplemental capital presents a number of regulatory and policy issues that would need to be addressed prior to authorizing this form of capital for all FICUs. The Board considered issuing an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking (“ANPR”) in the near future which would give credit unions and the public the opportunity to provide comment before the proposed rule stage. Supplemental capital does not provide any capital support under the NCUA’s net worth requirements because it does not count as equity under generally accepted accounting principles, but it would allow FICUs to have a greater concentration of member business loans and long term mortgage loans since it could be used by FICUs to meet...

Read Complete Article HERE>»

First-responder Credit Union Newsroom

Search This Blog